WHich team is better? (one that took 2 weeks or 5 mins)

[glam77]

One of these took 2 weeks to compile. 1 took 5 minutes to compile.
WHich do you think is better?

Rookies likely to look very simialr, and to be updated prior to Rd 1.



The Wrecked Ems
Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Bruce, Deledio, Adcock, Otten, Duigan (Toy, Hibberd, Puopolo)
Mids: Pendelbury, Bartel, Judd, Thompson, Swallow, Heppell (Harris, Atley, I Smith)
Ruck: Sandi, Cox (Trengove, Z Smith)
Fwds: Harvey, N Reiwoldt, Pav, Brown, Knights,Petrie, Karckour (Prestia, Mzungu, Tapscott)


Atomic Beefcake
Backs: Goddard, Scotland, Bruce, Broughton, Otten, Heppell, COad (Toy, Duigan, Puopolo)
Mids: Swan, Bartel, Gibbs, Thompson, ANthony, Harris (Pittard, Atley, Hibberd)
Rucks: Sandi, Cox (Petrie, Z SMith)
Fwds: Chappy, N Reiwoldt, Pav,Higgins, Knights, Prestia, Mzungu (Tapscott, I SMith, Callinan)

[glam77]

oh... and if voting please give a reason why you chose 1 side or the other if possible

[BGK]

Personally i don't really like either but i chose team 1. I think a mixture of both would be better. I like Broughton better than Bruce. I like Gibbs in the back line. I like NO Anthony in team 1. But i don't like Harvey and Brown in the forwards. I think there are better options. Brown is underpriced if he plays well. But i as well as most people were burnt by Brown last year and i think he will struggle even more this year. Harvey's age worries me.

Hope it helps.

[glam77]

Personally i don't really like either but i chose team 1. I think a mixture of both would be better. I like Broughton better than Bruce. I like Gibbs in the back line. I like NO Anthony in team 1. But i don't like Harvey and Brown in the forwards. I think there are better options. Brown is underpriced if he plays well. But i as well as most people were burnt by Brown last year and i think he will struggle even more this year. Harvey's age worries me.

Hope it helps.

I was thinking of going Brown to Higgins, but was gonna wait to see what happens in the coming weeks regarding injuries, cos as we know... both are pretty injury prone.

Burce is my 'unique'. Haven't seen him in too many sides.

Agree that there may be a good compromise between the 2 sides.

[ronl]

I think Bruce is a good pick.  He'll pay his way.
Brown still has groin trouble, big miss.
Harvey may be past it, but you never know.
Don't like Thompson, hopeless if he's tagged.
Higgins, great, but you'll probably only get 4-5 games before the niggles start.
Petrie better up forward for mine.
Go with Swan as leader.

[glam77]

I think Bruce is a good pick.  He'll pay his way.
Brown still has groin trouble, big miss.
Harvey may be past it, but you never know.
Don't like Thompson, hopeless if he's tagged.
Higgins, great, but you'll probably only get 4-5 games before the niggles start.
Petrie better up forward for mine.
Go with Swan as leader.

pretty much my thoughts on players i am concerned about.
the crows midfield will be looking quite different this season and i'm taking a bit of a punt on the fact that thompson steps up. Having avergaed in the high 90's the last 4 years, maybe he can push that into the 100's... maybe.