sherman instead of boyd

[cmgb84]

thinking of saving dollars and putting sherman in as a unique, in the hope he recaptures his DT form at the dogs. already have swan, bartel and murphy..so have enough premiums. will be very interested in his NAB form

post below as to why this is a crazy idea!! especially doggies fans who know how he is going

[CuStArDaRm]

boyds a gun sherm is not.
Risk is correct

[valkorum]

Someone has just read the latest article from Secret Squirrel ;)

[Zarts]

lol, I noticed that as well :P

[Chopps]

good reason boyd is 470 k because you know he will deliver

[RiOtChEsS]

[thatguy]

picking sherm as a unique mid priced isnt a bad move. comparing him to boyd is!

[Justin Bieber]

I love Boyd but can potential upside in Sherman. Although his X-Factor style makes him quite inconsistent. Should fit the Dogs lineup as they need speed to run the wings.

picking sherm as a unique mid priced isnt a bad move. comparing him to boyd is!

I totally agree with this. He could do well in a new team but the comparison is out the window in this one!! Boyd is a DT Gun 8).

P.S Got a spare minute, Go over to the FF Personality Of The Year thread and cast your votes!!! Pretty sure you have 4 votes so why not? Don't like the canidates, nominate yourself! All are welcomed. Might add you don't have to vote for me as there are many worthy canidates for votes. Vote for Bomberboy please :).
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23614.0.html

[browny_wce]

boyd - 2010 DT avg 115.2
sherman - 2010 DT avg 66.9

boyd - Dogs captain and best user of the ball by hand or foot at the club
sherman - new kid at the club, hit & miss style...waxes his legs  ::)

obvious choice here  ;)

[valkorum]

boyd - 2010 DT avg 115.2
sherman - 2010 DT avg 66.9

boyd - Dogs captain and best user of the ball by hand or foot at the club
sherman - new kid at the club, hit & miss style...waxes his legs  ::)

obvious choice here  ;)

I agree that Boyd is a better player than Sherman (both as a footy player and as a fantasy player) but surely Gilbee is the best user by foot at the Dogs.

[Holz]

Im tipping Boyd to have a chance of overtaking Swan this year.

[Justin Bieber]

boyd - 2010 DT avg 115.2
sherman - 2010 DT avg 66.9

boyd - Dogs captain and best user of the ball by hand or foot at the club
sherman - new kid at the club, hit & miss style...waxes his legs  ::)

obvious choice here  ;)

I agree that Boyd is a better player than Sherman (both as a footy player and as a fantasy player) but surely Gilbee is the best user by foot at the Dogs.

Gilbee by foot and Cross by hand (just because he does it so much :P).

Sherman is inconsistent and played for lowly Lions. It was for different teams so only time will tell if he will do well in a new home...

[j959]

no! don't do it!

but you can take him as a mid-pricer if you like ...

[McRooster]

Give yourself an uppercut! Sherman over Boyd  ::)

NEVVVVVVERRR!!

Although a few other dog decisions have me going in circles  :P

[steven_ora]

i think sherman will improve his average but wont be close to boyd!