joel vs jimmy

[ando_10]

4th mid

[popedelio]

Joel Corey because that'll leve with some extra cash in the kitty

[bjrouse]

Bartel

[Holz]

Bartel is probably abit past his best but for me corey is too old and also the injury last year worries me more than bartels injury

[Jimbo_11]

joel
jimmy will get the tag, joel will be able to run free and rack up the possies

[DTDreamer]

joel
jimmy will get the tag, joel will be able to run free and rack up the possies

I agree with picking Joel,
but there is no way Bartel will get first tag.

[ando_10]

cheers fellas but i will stick with corey

i dont think jimmy will get first tag selwood will 100%

but i think corey is so under rated and can get the job done if he stay un injured

[bluedreamin]

Bartel is an iron man. Still averaged 100+ with a stuffed elbow and playing off HFF.
Corey is made of glass. Like the bloke but he just gets injured too often.
Bartel all the way for me.

[Colty]

Bartel is an iron man. Still averaged 100+ with a stuffed elbow and playing off HFF.
Corey is made of glass. Like the bloke but he just gets injured too often.
Bartel all the way for me.

How can you say Corey is made of glass? last year was his first year injured for a significant time.

[Wild Thing]

Tough spot.  I had Selwood last year and Bartel in '09 and I had a marginally better year last year with Selwood than with Bartel the year before but I don't think you can go far wrong with either of them.  Flip a coin?  The question is...can you spend the extra $76,200 you get by picking Bartel over Selwood anywhere else to good effect???

[ELLsendon]

jimmy.

[bluedreamin]

Bartel is an iron man. Still averaged 100+ with a stuffed elbow and playing off HFF.
Corey is made of glass. Like the bloke but he just gets injured too often.
Bartel all the way for me.

How can you say Corey is made of glass? last year was his first year injured for a significant time.

Actually, fair call. I should check my stats. Last year was the only year in the last few where he has struggled. I guess the multiple times he broke down last year had me thinking it stretched a fair way back. I'd still take Jimmy, though.

[ando_10]

Tough spot.  I had Selwood last year and Bartel in '09 and I had a marginally better year last year with Selwood than with Bartel the year before but I don't think you can go far wrong with either of them.  Flip a coin?  The question is...can you spend the extra $76,200 you get by picking Bartel over Selwood anywhere else to good effect???

if ya read the poll wild thing youll find im talking about joel corey not joel selwood hahah

[Damoz Merry Men]

Bartel will be more consistent and play more games!

[cortez]

Joel Selwood for me :)