Created for my brother-in-law - am I being kind or mean??

[j959]

For brother-in-law Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition created by j959 for his brother-in-law. Salary cap left: $25,400.

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Brett Deledio, Jack Grimes, Andy Otten, Dyson Heppell, Brad Harvey
Bench:Peter Faulks, Nicholas Duigan, Paul Puopolo

Dane Swan, Matthew Boyd, Leigh Montagna, Liam Anthony, Nathan Foley, David Swallow
Bench:Andrew Gaff, Tendai Mzungu, Michael Hibberd

Dean Cox, Mitchell Clark
Bench:Zac Smith, Max Bailey

Colin Sylvia, Nick Riewoldt, Matthew Pavlich, Ryan O'Keefe, Cyril Rioli, Drew Petrie, Andrew Krakouer
Bench:Dion Prestia, Jack Darling, Ian Callinan

So, I'm not giving him my whole team, trying to make him a little unique -
I've loaded up the initial team here for him, he will take over and set up for Rd1 and beyond.

Just a bit of fun, getting some views on whether you think I am being too kind or too mean for his initial set-up to work on??

[XxBrayden]

Backs -  I like

Midfield- Liam Anthony could be a good pick up but if theres anywhere you think you can trim some fat in the budget id look to upgrade him

Rucks- Mitch Clark will be the weak link here, i find rucks rather important in dreamteam as alot of people forget to put money into them, Sandilands was the diference in my team a few times last year, consider an upgrade?

Forwards - Ryan Okeefe is some1 i will be watching during the pre season, I want to know if hes going to run through the midfield or be mainly a small forward as he hampered my forwardline last year when playing in the forward line

overall a dcent looking team at first look 7/10

[Joshy11]

Very solid backline but brad harvey?

I do like this midfield alot and i like foley but i think since his price increased after fanplanner he isnt worth that much cash and would rather go a rookie or dan harris or just start gaff and get a 92k rookie. But foly as a unique is fine :)

Rucks are risky with coxs age inj and less game time and mitch clark can be all over the place. Would like to atleast see sandi jolly or ryder in there.

Solid forwads. I like rok and cyril as there a lil different.

All in all a decent team without being amazing. 8/10

[j959]

cheers fellas, i think i have achieved my aim then from your comments - like i said i want to give him a decent and unique team but not give him everything from my bag of tricks so to speak.

Brad Harvey - how much more unique can I go??!   ;)

if you had rated it 6 or below then i would know that i was being mean to him!

agree with all your strategic comments (i'm just going to let him figure it out for himself though) so that is good for us all!

cheers,
j

[Joshy11]

Haha good man j :) wish him all the best :P