Gaff v Conca?

Started by kazam, February 09, 2011, 12:58:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Gaff or Conca?

Gaff
Conca
Get rid of Swallow and have both Gaff and Conca
Bite the bullet and get rid of Atley, Smith, Mzungu or Harris for Gaff and use up extra cap.

kazam

My mids are:

Swan, Gibbs, Bartel, Harris, D.Swallow, Mzungu (Conca, I.Smith, Atley)

I am happy playing 3 cheapies on the field... Happy with Atley, Smith and Mzungu for their prices, and just thinking bout getting Gaff in. Don't wanna have a heap of the dear draftees, so I want to keep the others, but think ing for roughly the same price, who's likely to play more and score better?

GAFF or CONCA?

RiOtChEsS

i think Gaff will have the best job security,
not too say Conca will struggle for a game...

both r very close in disposal efficiency Gaff has won more pill tho

craig22

i think u really need more talent in there 3 isnt enough i think

kazam

3 premiums? why not? Harris has played over 100 games, so could end up being a value of the premiums... and the others are cash cows who I will downgrade and upgrade over the year.

Nuffman

I vote Gaff.

Tigers midfield is full of youth atm which may affect Conca's JS.

In saying that he was rated extremely high at the draft camp.

Boomz

Quote from: Nuffman on February 09, 2011, 01:55:21 AM
I vote Gaff.

Tigers midfield is full of youth atm which may affect Conca's JS.

In saying that he was rated extremely high at the draft camp.

and WC's is full of gun mids?...

I think it's too early to call that best to watch them in the NAB but I think they will both get a lot of games.

8-6 Suited

Either way, they will both play. Hardwick loves rotating youths through where as Kerr will be back soon, could reduce Gaff's chances as well.

Bruizer81

My Mids are - Swan, Judd, J. Selwood, Deledio, D. Swallow, Gaff EMER - Polec, Mzunga, Altey

Will Polec get more games than Conca???

Think with the Lions midfield getting old and the losses of Rischetelli and Brennan Polec could see more game time...

Thoughts???

kazam

that's enough one too. If I am worried at all, I can send Krakouer or Prestia into my mids for SMith and play one of them in the midfield with Conca/Gaff/Harris/Swallow/Mzungu/Atley... Yes Polec is another one as well. In an ideal world I'd love to have my mid rookies/cheapies as Polec, Gaff, Swallow, Conca, Mzungu and Harris, but that just costs too much haha. Im thinkin Atley could be a steal for his price. Slot nicely into FWD flank and midfield with Ziebell, Swallow, Adams, Harvey.

RiOtChEsS


kazam


Nuffman

Quote from: BOOMZ on February 09, 2011, 02:59:07 AM
and WC's is full of gun mids?...

I think it's too early to call that best to watch them in the NAB but I think they will both get a lot of games.

If WCE's mids were full of guns I wouldn't have voted for Gaff...

CuStArDaRm

craig 22 3's not enough????
Clearly your not too good at this game