..call me crazy - but no swan or ablett??

[Luigi197]

must have Goddard
u can get away with no Ablett or Swan.
as long as you have Pendles, Hodge, Selwood or Boyd or Joey in there

[Swallow12]

Seriously? Starting Petrie on the bench? Okay get rid of one of your foward rookies, start petrie and put J.Tippet in the 3rd ruck spot. Also Downgrade Pendlebury to a rookie and start Mzungu. Use the cash to upgrade a forward rookie. Also Get Goddard purely for Captaincy

[Alex7089]

I'm not taking Swan, or Ablett. Too many question marks for Ablett, and I prefer Pendles over Swan, at least until Collingwood has had their byes.
As was said above if you don't pick Goddard you will be left behind, he is the new Ablett ;)

[pyronerd]

I'm not taking Swan, or Ablett. Too many question marks for Ablett, and I prefer Pendles over Swan, at least until Collingwood has had their byes.
As was said above if you don't pick Goddard you will be left behind, he is the new Ablett ;)

only better :P

[theta]

Seriously? Starting Petrie on the bench? Okay get rid of one of your foward rookies, start petrie and put J.Tippet in the 3rd ruck spot. Also Downgrade Pendlebury to a rookie and start Mzungu. Use the cash to upgrade a forward rookie. Also Get Goddard purely for Captaincy

good points, but have a couple of questions for ya.

1. yeah you are right about petrie, i thought his stats were lower, was thinking more of value than points.  how is petrie's recovery/preseason going?

2. drop pendles for a rookie?  that would mean a lot of extra cash left over and a significantly weaker midfield.  is that not pushing the envelope for the amount of rookies a little too far risk-wise?

3. i assume tippett is only there for the mpp swap with petrie.  is tippett expected to get much game time with smith, gorringe and fraser around? 

3. which forward rookie would you suggest? - (i know there are plenty, i dont expect an answer on that one)

4. god captain for sure.  no question here.

[uteboy]

YOU  think your crazy i dont have any of the big big gun in my midfield, I have gone with

Foley, sidebottom, sherman, slone, gaff, swallow (GC) BENCH- polec, conca,beams,

just want to be different...

[CuStArDaRm]

no swan or ablett!??? ok you do that gives me auto ride to top 100