David Swallow how many people are NOT getting him?

Started by Usman, February 07, 2011, 09:38:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

CuStArDaRm

Dont have either Swallow or Bennell.
Didnt have Scully or Trengrove either and was just fine.
Did have Pods, Rocky & Barlow though ;)

Alex7089

I'm going with Swallow.
Although if he fails he is straight on the bench and on comes Harris, while Swallow will be sold after he makes money :P

Junktimer



batch

I reckon Harris is much better value and dont want two GC in my mids so no Swallow for me unless the NAB really changes my mind

Usman

its not a case of Swallow failing, thatwont happen.

its a case of how well will he actually go? personally i dont think he will avg anymore than 85 but no less than 70 

Junktimer

i dont see any problem in getting both him and harris

freaks

Swallow is better then his brother or cousin or whatever relation he is and the other swallow is a FREAK

roo boys!

Quote from: freaks on February 08, 2011, 12:25:24 AM
Swallow is better then his brother or cousin or whatever relation he is and the other swallow is a FREAK
No-one is better than A. Swallow -__-

Usman

Quotei dont see any problem in getting both him and harris

I agree

Alex7089

Quote from: roo boys! on February 08, 2011, 05:59:58 PM
Quote from: freaks on February 08, 2011, 12:25:24 AM
Swallow is better then his brother or cousin or whatever relation he is and the other swallow is a FREAK
No-one is better than A. Swallow -__-
Yes, clearly you are not influenced by...anything :P
D. Swallow is not better than A. Swallow YET but he will be a fair bit better IMO.

Zarts

eh, go harris and swallow, providing you can cover round 1. If by GC second bye, you can't cover them both, sell off whichever one has the least potential of fattening up still.

it's not really, that risky, unless you expect gold coast to get utterly annihilated this season. 

ladasp

locked in harris, swallow may be good, but so was scully, had him last year and as always rookies are up and down unless they are barlow the boy was gold till he broke his leg.shame. top picks always seem to draw more attention 2. guess im just hopin harris is more consistant. i like the look of mature age cheapies!

bkimm32

At first I was thinking Swallow would be an automatic lock in all teams. After thinking about it, maybe not so much. I can see him averaging perhaps 75-85 tops. Although he will most likely play all season, at close to 190k there are so many options who could all average the same, perhaps more, for a lot less base price.

If he can prove to me in the NAB that he can score 85+ he will be in my team.

enzedder

Pretty sure I'll have him. Depends on cheaper rookies/ exposed NAB form and named R1 teams of course but can't really see not having him.