heath shaw

[steven_ora]

Ok so i know alot of you dont pick heath shaw due to inconsistency... but looking at other defenders in that price range they all have inconsistency issues eg. duffield, fisher, grimes, hurn.

heath shaw has been a proven peformer over the last 5 years averaging over 100 twice and over 90 three times. Now playing for the strongest team in the AFL could this be the year he gets his average back over 100?

From all reports he has had an un-interrupted pre season and im thinking either him or duffield?

[ELLsendon]

What about his brother?

[tferrier18]

Won't be a bad pick...he tends to perform a bit better after the mid-season break which is a bit odd...

There's not a whole lot of merit to that theory because there's no real reason why it should occur, so I wouldn't expect it to occur again...I don't think he's a bad pick. Leon davis has been training as a hbf'er so he might draw a defensive tag from oppositions...Could mean less attention for heater!

Worth a punt.

[RiOtChEsS]

under consideration thats for sure...

[steven_ora]

i cant split him and duffield so i think im just going to wait for the nab cup and base my choice on their peformances their?

[RiOtChEsS]

if u hav Broughton it would be Shaw otherwise id go Duff

[nas]

maybe the 2 Shaw's = a definite Shaw thing

[Junktimer]

exactly the type of defender you should be looking at.  A Shaw thing.

[tferrier18]

I'm guessing he's your 4th defender?

[Junktimer]

6th  :)

[Usman]

exactly the type of defender you should be looking at.  A Shaw thing.

Im guessing you have the AFL Prospectus  :)

[nas]

Could be another roller coaster ride tho with his scores.

[Usman]

 

Could be another roller coaster ride tho with his scores. 

No doubt and when you have players like that you are better off picking them up during the year when they have enevitabley dropped in price due to inconsitency. 

[steven_ora]

if im going for league win it is still ok to have broughton and duffman correct??

[Prospector_1]

Could be another roller coaster ride tho with his scores.

Always is!