My 2011 Team

[roo boys!]

Here's my SC team:
Backs: Goddard  Gibbs    Jacobs
       Duffield  Bock  Puopolo  Heppell
(Toy, Newman, Guthrie)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Ablett  Hodge  Moloney
(Didak, Deledio, Irons)

Rucks: Cox   Petrie
(J.Tippett, Spencer)

Forwards:  Talia  Pavlich  Chapman
                Rioli         Franklin   Lobbe  Mzungu
(Richardson, N.Roo, Higgins)

Bank: $7,200
Trades: 4

[Luigi197]

Here's my SC team:
Backs: Goddard  Lake  Gilbee
       Duffield  Bock  McGuire  Otten
(Toy, Dare, McGovern)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Delidio  Anthony  D.Swallow
(Prestia, Atley, Andrieoli)

Rucks:  Sandilands  Petrie
(Z.Smith, McCauley)

Forwards:  N.Reiwoldt  Pavlich  Brown
           Tippet  Krakouer  Day  Richardson
(Mzungu, Darling, T.Schneider)

Bank: $17,300

Forwards need work :-\

Doesnt look bad.. glad youve got some uniques in there, and your benches arent too bad...
Yatde one of Lake or Gilbee to Gibbs or Hurn for money and coz u got the 2 from the same team...
Good luck with McGuire ;)
Nice mids and rucks..
You want more guns in your ruck so start by downgrading Anthony to Gaff and Trade Lake...
Use that money Day to a mid-pricer and Tippet up 2 a gun..

Luigi :)

[McRooster]

The way I look at a team looking for a rating is that each player potentially has 1 point.
eg. I am giving your backline 7/10.
This 7/10 is coverted back to a line score out of 2.5 (representing the 1/4 total of 10 in the overall rating).
thus backs are 1.75  ;)
My key concerns...
Lake has had more surgery, Bock is a spud and spent most of last season in a moon boot, and Otten's future will be clearer in a week.

Mids-2.5
My key concerns...
Nil (other than the extra Roo)

Rucks-2.5
My key concerns...
Broc McCauley, but really a 4th ruck matters little in the grand scheme

Fwds-1.25/2.5
My key concerns...
Johnno Browns fitness and his determination to play whislt injured (this allows his scores and value to slide), Tippetts inconsistency and lack of designated field position often sees him roaming lost on the field and not really knowing what to do, Krakoeur, Day and Richardson and lack of possible TOG for them.

Total 8/10

Lazily I haven't sunk into the depths of investigating your MPP fully or your bye clashes, this may take more points off I'd suggest rather than increase.
You know and I know there is much more time to go before the season proper begins and that this side will change in structure a couple more times yet, as will mine.
You're probably going to have to cull a Roo  :'(

[ando_10]

maybe ya forwards need work cuz ya one player top heavy in the mids downgrade one to a rookie like gaff then upgrade one of ya forwards
thats my only concern really
8/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,24981.0.html

[roo boys!]

Thanks everyone :)

Yeah Luigi, I think I am going to trade McGuire down to a rookie and use that cash to upgrade one of Krak/Richardson(no way! ;)) or Day.

Thanks Roost :)
Yeah McCauley is just a cheap filler. I just saw yesterday that Lake has made a full recovery and they expect him to play NAB cup game 1. I believe that Bock was just managed badly :P Nah but seriously I am hoping he can lead the young GC back line.
Yeah the extra Roo is a concern, but I love em all :-\
I will keep A.Swallow, and Atley is value for money...Anthony? :-\

I am trying to keep Tippet for MPP with Petrie.

Thanks ando, I think I will upgrade one of the cheap forwards :)

[roo boys!]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/dogs-stars-to-miss-opener/story-e6frf9jf-1225997037830

Oh no :'( Will keep Lake for now but will probably play around with the backline for the next few weeks.

Okay, traded out Anthony for Gaff, and upgraded McGuire to Hurn. Have 141k to upgrade one of my forwards...

Team looks like this:
Backs: Goddard  Lake  Gilbee
       Duffield  Bock  Hurn  Otten
(Toy, Dare, McGovern)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Delidio  D.Swallow  Gaff
(Prestia, Atley, Andrieoli)

Rucks:  Sandilands  Petrie
(Z.Smith, McCauley)

Forwards:  N.Reiwoldt  Pavlich  Brown
           Tippet  Krakouer  Day  Richardson
(Mzungu, Darling, T.Schneider)

[Barlow 21]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/dogs-stars-to-miss-opener/story-e6frf9jf-1225997037830

Oh no :'( Will keep Lake for now but will probably play around with the backline for the next few weeks.

Okay, traded out Anthony for Gaff, and upgraded McGuire to Hurn. Have 141k to upgrade one of my forwards...

Team looks like this:
Backs: Goddard  Lake  Gilbee
       Duffield  Bock  Hurn  Otten
(Toy, Dare, McGovern)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Delidio  D.Swallow  Gaff
(Prestia, Atley, Andrieoli)

Rucks:  Sandilands  Petrie
(Z.Smith, McCauley)

Forwards:  N.Reiwoldt  Pavlich  Brown
           Tippet  Krakouer  Day  Richardson
(Mzungu, Darling, T.Schneider)

]
Very Solid RB. I don`t like Tippet and Bock but they could turn out to be nice unique picks. (Tippett 6% and Bock 11%) Overall it deserves a 9/10

[roo boys!]

Thanks Barlow :) Good to see that Bock only has 11%, I have a feeling that he is going to be my unique smokie.

Who do you guys think I should upgrade with my 141k? Day to a mid-pricer...?

[Hippo]

i reckon Day too Callinan which will make you 90k to go with your 140k

then use that 230k too upgrade Tippet to a premo

8/10 i like the uniqueness aswell

[roo boys!]

But what about the MPP between Tippet and Petrie? :-\

[Nuffman]

But what about the MPP between Tippet and Petrie? :-\

I'm assuming from his placing in the forward line that he is Tippet from the Crows. there is a rookie Tippet, same MPP (RUC/FWD).

Trade to him

[Hippo]

myself i wouldn't worry about mpp with the rucks

If you put Bailey in there instead off McCauly to go with Smith and he doesn't get injured then they should play everygame anyway which provides cover, thats the only reason you would use the mpp... for cover which you would have anyway imo

i think you should have Heppal inthere somewhere too

[roo boys!]

Alright thanks. How about this?:

McCauley to Bailey
Day to Callinan
Tippet to Didak

Leaves my team like this:
Backs: Goddard  Lake  Gilbee
       Duffield  Bock  Hurn  Otten
(Toy, Dare, McGovern)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Delidio  D.Swallow  Gaff
(Prestia, Atley, Andrieoli)

Rucks:  Sandilands  Petrie
(Z.Smith, Bailey)

Forwards:  N.Reiwoldt  Pavlich  Brown
           Krakouer  Didak  Mzungu Richardson
(Callinan, Darling, T.Schneider)

35k left over?

[Luigi197]

Alright thanks. How about this?:

McCauley to Bailey
Day to Callinan
Tippet to Didak

Leaves my team like this:
Backs: Goddard  Lake  Gilbee
       Duffield  Bock  Hurn  Otten
(Toy, Dare, McGovern)

Mids:  Swan  Judd
       A.Swallow  Delidio  D.Swallow  Gaff
(Prestia, Atley, Andrieoli)

Rucks:  Sandilands  Petrie
(Z.Smith, Bailey)

Forwards:  N.Reiwoldt  Pavlich  Brown
           Krakouer  Didak  Mzungu Richardson
(Callinan, Darling, T.Schneider)

35k left over?

like it.. but would downgrade A Swallow to a unique mid-pricer for money.. then use that money to fix my other flaw 2 startin rooky forwards, mayb  upgrade T Schneider to a unique mid-pricer

[roo boys!]

I'm not really for mid-pricers, and I love A.Swallow.. :-\