current lineup, pre NAB

Torress · February 04, 2011, 03:21:02 PM

only $77,300 remaining - will prob be looking for atleast 150k in kitty for start of season

Backs - GOD, lids, gibbs, broughton, hurn, otten, heppel
emg - coad, toy, talia

Mids - tags, pendles, boyd, jack, d.swallow, gaff
emg - callinan, mzunga, jacobs

Ruck - ryder, leunberger
emg- bailey, smith

Forwards - Chappy, roo, buddy, pav, petrie, krakoeur, richardson
emg- matera, tapscott, i.smith

if i get comments it'll be about the ruck i'm sure! but hey i see upside in both rucks as they will have bigger ruck duties in 2011 for their respected sides. and its not a lock its just early days people! not that sure on back rookies we'll see how it pans out

benjy251090 · February 04, 2011, 03:30:58 PM

First question, are you going for league or overall?

also, not a fan of the berger, rather you go petrie there or something, you could also downgrade one of tags, pendles, boyd or jack as there are quite a few good rookies this year.

Apart from that, it is not a bad team. 7/10

tferrier18 · February 04, 2011, 03:31:48 PM

I like it a lot, before i rate though are you going for league win or overall?

thanks

Luigi197 · February 04, 2011, 10:12:05 PM

Quote from: Torress on February 04, 2011, 03:21:02 PM
only $77,300 remaining - will prob be looking for atleast 150k in kitty for start of season

Backs - GOD, lids, gibbs, broughton, hurn, otten, heppel
emg - coad, toy, talia

Mids - tags, pendles, boyd, jack, d.swallow, gaff
emg - callinan, mzunga, jacobs

Ruck - ryder, leunberger
emg- bailey, smith

Forwards - Chappy, roo, buddy, pav, petrie, krakoeur, richardson
emg- matera, tapscott, i.smith

if i get comments it'll be about the ruck i'm sure! but hey i see upside in both rucks as they will have bigger ruck duties in 2011 for their respected sides. and its not a lock its just early days people! not that sure on back rookies we'll see how it pans out

like the backs alot though Otten got injured in an Intra club match so c how he shapes up NAB... and loosed up on the GCS in that backbench
Would try get at-least Judd in there for Montagna...and Heppel is a sick man ATM.
Not gonna judge your rucks, too hard to say ATM
Would replace Chappy with a cheaper premium the upgrade Krak to a unique mid-pricer

u wanna get unique mid-pricer so it separates your team from everyone elses, u just gotta take a chance..

Luigi :)

Nuffman · February 04, 2011, 10:35:09 PM

He means, Jacobs is sick, not Heppell :P

bottlemart · February 04, 2011, 10:49:12 PM

good team. I like joey montagna as a SC player, and i would favour him over judd (nothing against judd, hes a gun aswell). but so is joey and saints have only only one bye whereas carlton have two byes and one of those byes is in finals, so i would definately keep joey. That's my opinion though and others may differ.

as mentioned re the rucks, my only suggestion if you were to get rid of berger would be replace him with tippet, so it gives you the tippet/petrie mpp, one in the ruck and the other in the forward line.

otherwise team looks good.

Luigi197 · February 04, 2011, 10:50:43 PM

Quote from: Nuffman on February 04, 2011, 10:35:09 PM
He means, Jacobs is sick, not Heppell :P

woops yep ;)

Torress · February 05, 2011, 04:44:41 PM

cheers 4 replies appreciate it.
gee overall or league?? i wanna do as best i can overall but when it gets t finals u just want to beat ur mates don't ya?? - obtaining a team of guns is the goal, how high overall u can go is obvious within 1st few weeks in a way.
so i guess a bit of both there lads.

after NAB we'll have some idea of a few of the younger guys, and hence play with our structure accordingly.
chappy is locked in love the way he goes about it, gun! burger - yea i agree yet i'm not touching sandi from the start, i think petrie is the obvious replacement, and i can't do tippet again! i guess downgrading a mid for a mid pricer could work- it'll be liam anthony if any. i would drop tags out of the four as i already have 2 saints, and only 1 swan/dog/pie prems. i'm not really gonna chop and change just yet, need more info(NAB)

i feel what ur saying about unique luigi, but i'll stick with krak like everyone else, mpp and set for games and good ceiling, i can't go past that for 200k mate. time to goto work, and ponder. happy SCing boys

tnator · February 05, 2011, 05:46:12 PM

QuoteHe means, Jacobs is sick, not Heppell :P

Phwew. I was getting worried there.

Quotei'll stick with krak like everyone else,

I think you have to have Krak at the moment. If the intra club game transforms to the NAB cup then he's a lock

current lineup, pre NAB

tferrier18