burgoyne vs bartel

[ando_10]

bit of a dilema jimmy or burgoyne?

[RiOtChEsS]

JimBob

[hawk_88]

Asked myself that same question and I picked Burgoyne, not because he is a Hawk but I think he has more upside.

[pyronerd]

Asked myself that same question and I picked Burgoyne, not because he is a Hawk but I think he has more upside.

+1, will avg around the same i think and burgoyne is slightly cheaper

[DamenS]

Both injured at the moment   :'(

[hawk_88]

Details?

[PiggyPommy]

Bartel. Not injured, Damen said something about him having the brace on his arm still, just a precaution im sure.

[DamenS]

Yeah - with Bartel he is still recovering from his elbow of last year ... they are saying he is 2 weeks away ... with Burgoyne I am not sure what the problem is (if I remember his past issues it was usually his hamstrings I think), but they were saying he won't play in the All-Stars game due to injury (though he is still part of the "leadership group").

[DamenS]

Here's the link to the Bartel one - say he is in rehab and 1-2 weeks away ... of course, Jimmy was actually PLAYING with a bung elbow towards the end of last year, so I doubt it will really affect him too greatly !

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/afl-summer-ready-to-sizzle/story-e6frf9jf-1225996745483

[DT Junkie]

Burgoyne has and will always have knee related issues for the rest of his career a bit like Mcleod did

[Gooner]

Burgoyne for sure if you're playing for finals.

[DamenS]

Burgoyne has and will always have knee related issues for the rest of his career a bit like Mcleod did

And Bernie Vince ... and Kurt Tippett ... having a degenerative knee condition has clearly become a requirement for playing AFL in S.A.  !! :o