Player X vs Player Y

[Maca24]

Ok i remember someone started this last year (think it was alex?)
This is to save from all the new threads clogging up the board.
Ill start things of by posting two players.
eg. Jimmy Bartel or Lenny Hayes?
Then someone will give their opinion and will ask a question of there own and so on. this will allow people to ask and recieve questions/answers.
So if youy want 2-4 players compared against each other because your not sure who to pick then post in here and hopefully everyone gets answered.

[BoredSaint]

yeah good idea maca,
ill start it off
Nathan Foley or Liam Anthony

[ando_10]

yeah good idea maca,
ill start it off
Nathan Foley or Liam Anthony

tough one mate i think anthony though i think foley will stuggle finding his feet again.

A.swallow or priddis?

[Hawka]

Gibbs or Delido

[Barlow 21]

I`d go A.Swallow as he should improve agin in 2011.

[Fletch74]

Gibbs or Delido

Delidio as Carlton have the bye in Rd 23, and I don't want to be using a trade on a premium for the finals.

Ryder or Jolly

[HillHero13]

Ryder for scoring, but bye in rd 24

Jolly for non bye in rd 24.

[Jas 13]

As much as it pains me to say it, Jolly.
Ryder’s role in the bomber’s side under Hird still has question marks (he’ll play but what position for the majority of the time on-field?)
Jolly is number 1 ruck at the pies, will play and had a strong 2nd half to the 2010 season
Will only get better with understanding the pies mids.

Jimmy Bartel vs Brad Sewell

[superstar]

Gibbs, as Carlton will flog richmond in the first round. You should be able to sub out Gibbs in round 23 with Duigan / Heppell by that stage. Which will be the next Barlow??
Kruezer or Cox

[ronl]

Probably Bartel by a whisker but a lot of ifs on both players.
Cox over Kreuzer as we don't know how he'll pull up after the acl.

GOODES V SYLVIA

[Nathans Brawlers]

Goodes was inconsistent last year but finished the year pretty good. im not to sure how slyvia went last year but he is $30000 cheaper. id go with slyvia.
I have 3 players if thats ok :)
ROK vs GIA vs S.JOHNSON

[MTTY]

Rioli V Franklin

[Junktimer]

Sylvia.

Franklin.

GRIMES VS BOCK

[Nathans Brawlers]

i say Bock, not as many good players to take points away from him, apart from harbrow.
ROK v S.JOHNSON v GIA

[Junktimer]

ROK