Jacobs vs Heppell

Started by LiveTheDream, January 26, 2011, 01:52:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who do you take?

Heppell
Jacobs

LiveTheDream

Last spot in the defense is vacant and I can only fit one of these promising youngsters. Vote and share any reasons or info that helped you decide.

At the moment i'm leaning towards Heppell simply because I feel he has better job security at the bombers, plus he's almost guaranteed to start round 1. Very tough call though

Boomz

Niether are almost guaranteed games that's impossible to know at this stage but have heard good things about Jacobs in all reports about port training... I'd personally go Jacobs because I don't think there will be much difference between the 2 and he's a fair bit cheaper.

dylsta05

50/50, but IMO heppell but thats just might be because im  a ess supporter

LiveTheDream

There has just been so many good reports on Heppell recently and at the same time I've hardly heard anything about Jacobs, despite being from Adelaide

dylsta05

yea i think heppell will score more IMO but im sure theres other people who can say the same thing for jacobs but ive heard better stuff for heppell

MTTY

For me i would go Jacobs as he can play a Goddard type role, also he is likened to Hodge and he racked up the possies at the Under 18 champs and was pretty effective

dylsta05

Quote from: MTTY on January 26, 2011, 05:05:08 PM
For me i would go Jacobs as he can play a Goddard type role, also he is likened to Hodge and he racked up the possies at the Under 18 champs and was pretty effective
really? sound good as i havnt heard much from him

DamenS

Pretty much a toss-of the-coin really; both have a reasonable chance of getting good game time, both are ball-magnets and highly skilled - one thing which probably just sways me towards Heppell is that he is far more likely to play midfield at this stage of his career and in their respective teams.

dylsta05

Quote from: DamenS on January 26, 2011, 07:01:38 PM
Pretty much a toss-of the-coin really; both have a reasonable chance of getting good game time, both are ball-magnets and highly skilled - one thing which probably just sways me towards Heppell is that he is far more likely to play midfield at this stage of his career and in their respective teams.
heppell will be a back/mid

bomberboy0618

Im going the risk and picking both as starters :)

dylsta05

Quote from: bomberboy0618 on January 26, 2011, 07:09:24 PM
Im going the risk and picking both as starters :)
thats what i have dont i took jacobs instead of otten

bomberboy0618


dylsta05

wow could turn out really great or really bad, i got drummond istead :O

Master Q

Jacobs, but it doesn't really matter.

Luigi197

y bother asking? Heppel all the way if u can. thogh Jacobs is still good