rate my mpp team

[nostradamus]

think l have finally worked it out......heres my team... can u rate it for me

mpp Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by nostrdamus. Salary cap left: $128,200.

Brendon Goddard, Brian Lake, Bryce Gibbs, Brett Deledio, Nathan Bock, Andy Otten, Ben Jacobs
Peter Faulks, Michael Hibberd, Bryce Retzlaff

Dane Swan, Brent Stanton, David Swallow, Nathan Foley, Brock McLean, Dyson Heppell
Andrew Krakouer, Tendai Mzungu, Ian Callinan

Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
Zac Smith, Tom McDonald

Paul Chapman, Lance Franklin, Alan Didak, Colin Sylvia, Nick Riewoldt, Drew Petrie, Dion Prestia
Isaac Smith, Cameron Richardson, Daniel Talia

[McRooster]

think l have finally worked it out......heres my team... can u rate it for me

mpp Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by nostrdamus. Salary cap left: $128,200.

Brendon Goddard 4/14, Brian Lake 4/20, Bryce Gibbs 8/23, Brett Deledio 11/19, Nathan Bock 1/9, Andy Otten 2/16, Ben Jacobs 12/18
Peter Faulks 6/16, Michael Hibberd 10/24, Bryce Retzlaff 4/19

Dane Swan 7/13, Brent Stanton 10/24, David Swallow 1/9, Nathan Foley 11/19, Brock McLean 8/23, Dyson Heppell 10/24
Andrew Krakouer 7/13, Tendai Mzungu 6/16, Ian Callinan 2/16

Aaron Sandilands 6/16, Darren Jolly 7/13
Zac Smith 1/9, Tom McDonald 5/16

Paul Chapman 6/22, Lance Franklin 6/17, Alan Didak 7/13, Colin Sylvia 5/16, Nick Riewoldt 4/14, Drew Petrie 3/21, Dion Prestia 1/9
Isaac Smith 6/17, Cameron Richardson 3/21, Daniel Talia 2/16

By rnd 16 a lot will have changed but keep in mind ATM you have 8 players in rnd 16 that have a bye and you have 6 missing in rnd 6.
Plus you have Bock, which I don't like and your mids are very light on. Maybe get Polec in the mid for Krakouer and upgrade Mclean (you already have strong MPP on the mid bench so a stay at home mid bench in Polec won't hurt)

[nostradamus]

thx Mc rooster.......was thinkin of upgrading krak to D.Harris now that he's in the leadership group at GC.......guaranteed games

[knightmare]

Lake is a dangerous starter considering he has had 2 different surgeries during the off season. Hes definatley on my radar but after 5-6games after his initial price drop.
Rookies Faulks, Retzlaff, Callinan, MacDonald and maybe Talia. These guys im unsure will play 12 games But u may something i dont do your research and maybe they will be big cash cows.
Foley and McLean are risks but so are Ottens, Petrie Chris Knights and Petterd. We are all trying to predict which ones are best.

[nostradamus]

 
: knightmare  : Today at 10:58:20 PM 

Lake is a dangerous starter considering he has had 2 different surgeries during the off season. Hes definatley on my radar but after 5-6games after his initial price drop.
Rookies Faulks, Retzlaff, Callinan, MacDonald and maybe Talia. These guys im unsure will play 12 games But u may something i dont do your research and maybe they will be big cash cows.
Foley and McLean are risks but so are Ottens, Petrie Chris Knights and Petterd. We are all trying to predict which ones are best

thx nightmare,

will be watchin lake over pre-season as with all rookies.....

if talia is fit l think he'll play
callinan is mature age rookie and was recruited for a reason
dont think mcdonald will play just there for mpp
retzlaff havin good pre-season....so far...also good 4 mpp with talia
but there are many others l'm lookin at too
mclean may be injured and am thinkin about harris or houli

[Chopps]

i think alot of people are neglecting round 6 and using their MPP for petrie.

for me this leaves your team very vulnerable.

best way to show this is move your players around


Dane Swan 7/13, Brent Stanton 10/24, David Swallow 1/9, Nathan Foley 11/19, Brock McLean 8/23, Dyson Heppell 10/24
Andrew Krakouer 7/13, Tendai Mzungu 6/16, Paul Chapman 6/22,


Drew Petrie 3/21, Darren Jolly 7/13
Zac Smith 1/9, Aaron Sandilands 6/16

Alan Didak 7/13, Colin Sylvia 5/16, Nick Riewoldt 4/14, Dion Prestia 1/9, Daniel Talia 2/16,Cameron Richardson 3/21,Ian Callinan 2/16,
Tom McDonald 5/16, Lance Franklin 6/17, Isaac Smith 6/17

for me your relying on alot of things to go your way, if mcdonald or krakouer dont play your going in with no forward or mid cover, not to mention 6 rookies and 2 iffy players, not taking backs into account

[nostradamus]

thx for the feedback chopps,
the probs u raised are good.....
l dont expect mcdonald to play, he's there for mpp ruck cover ....
as for krak & smith, they're not set in stone and will go with best options over pre-season.....
l've been tinkering with line-up and will post updated version soon

again thx for constructive comments

[nostradamus]

heres my updated version 4 u 2 look at.....
feel free to comment

mpp Fanplanner squad in the Dream Team competition coached by nostrdamus. Salary cap left: $91,800.

Brendon Goddard, Brian Lake, Bryce Gibbs, Brett Deledio, Nathan Bock, Andy Otten, Dyson Heppell
Josh Toy, Nicholas Duigan, Paul Puopolo

Dane Swan, Leigh Montagna, David Swallow, Daniel Harris, Nathan Foley, Ben Jacobs
Michael Hibberd, Tendai Mzungu, Ian Callinan

Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
Zac Smith, Tom McDonald

Paul Chapman, Lance Franklin, Alan Didak, Nick Riewoldt, Jonathan Brown, Drew Petrie, Dion Prestia
Andrew Krakouer, Brandon Matera, Cameron Richardson


l've gone high risk..... so many GC

l think l've got good balance  with mpps

and have gone cash cows 4 midfield

tried for set and forget backs, rucks and fwds

[knightmare]

What do people think of MPP in the rucks with Petrie. Tom McDonald gives u the option to move Petrie into ruck for cover, i understand that. But why not just pick a cheapie thats going to play, I doubt McDonald will get a game so it seems a waste to me.
David Hale is only a little more expensive and very likely to play 50% + games.

Your team looks good Bock is unique but should be worth his value. Daniel Harris should be a great cash cow. Watching Foley's preseason. Chapman might lose a little value but is always gonna be a gun.

[nostradamus]

All good ppoints Nightmare,

l get what u mean about mpp, petrie,mcdonald situation.....l just think petrie is too good to hav sitting on ruck bench......and l want him because l think he'll b a great cash cow to upgrade

Having said that hav been thinkin of M.Clarke instead of jolly??????
and really like bailey as a bench ruck........depending on pre-season

thx 4 ur feedback pal