Fresh Team! Ill rate yours :)

[Maca24]

New team! Fanplanner has changed a fair bit so ive used alot of MPP.

Backs:
Goddard, Deledio, Gibbs, Broughton, Drummond, Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench: Duigan, Illes, Toy.

Mids
Swan, Watson, A.Swallow, D.Swallow, Gaff, I.Smith.
Bench: Hibberd, Mzungu, J.Green.

Rucks:
Sandilands and Petrie.
Bench: Bailey and Smith.

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, L.Franklin, Didak, Pavlich, Goodes, Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench: Darling, Tapscott, C.Richardson.

MPPs are Hibberd with Heppell, Jacobs, GOD etc. Centre and Back
and mzungu and I.Smith with Prestia, Pav, Dids etc. Centre and Forward
BANK: 35K.

[BoredSaint]

dont really like that midfield.. a bit risky starting 3 rookies..

[Poa Free]

Overall I really like your team, maybe just starting 2 rookies in your backline maybe a little of a worry, really like the forward line plenty of potential points there.

I think alot of people, I know I will be starting 3 rookie mids.

9/10

[Maca24]

dont really like that midfield.. a bit risky starting 3 rookies..

worked for me last year, its the way to go.
thatnks poa for the feedback.
jacobs and heppell are great rookies though and id consider them better than otten.

[BoredSaint]

ive never done it.. so maybe it works.. could try it in one of my other teams just for fun.. :P

[Knowall]

Defence is faultless.
Mids having 3 prem and 3 rookie im not a fan of need a mid pricer at least instead of 3 rookies.  I like watson and swallow though as prems
Rucks are standard
FWD is nice! Fairly safe as well cant really fault it. 

Maybe downgrade goodes and upgrade a mid rookie
9/10

Rate Mine?
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23877.0.html

[Boomz]

New team! Fanplanner has changed a fair bit so ive used alot of MPP.

Backs:
Goddard, Deledio, Gibbs, Broughton, Drummond, Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench: Duigan, Illes, Toy.

Mids
Swan, Watson, A.Swallow, D.Swallow, Gaff, I.Smith.
Bench: Hibberd, Mzungu, J.Green.

Rucks:
Sandilands and Petrie.
Bench: Bailey and Smith.

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, L.Franklin, Didak, Pavlich, Goodes, Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench: Darling, Tapscott, C.Richardson.

BANK: 35K.

Def: Very good no problems.

Mid: Personally I don't mind starting 3 rookies but I see Watson as a weak link because of the RD 24 bye (waste of a trade) and better options at his price.

Ruck: Very good.

Fwd: Only thing I don't like is Goodes but he could be good if he plays in the middle.

9/10 :D

[Maca24]

thanks for the rates guys. ill rate your teams now.

[4820]

Iilses (GC) listed in the 2011 prospectus as a mid. I hope the prospectus is wrong and he is a back ! For info.

[Maca24]

ok thanks mate. probs will still consider..

[enzedder]

dont really like that midfield.. a bit risky starting 3 rookies..

So long as you choose the right ones it is the way to go...
Last year if you had Barlow Trengrove Martin as starters with say  Bastinac and Banner or Moles on the bench you were laughing.

[Maca24]

agreed. theres no doubt ill be using this strategy.

[Luigi197]

New team! Fanplanner has changed a fair bit so ive used alot of MPP.

Backs:
Goddard, Deledio, Gibbs, Broughton, Drummond, Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench: Duigan, Illes, Toy.

Mids
Swan, Watson, A.Swallow, D.Swallow, Gaff, I.Smith.
Bench: Hibberd, Mzungu, J.Green.

Rucks:
Sandilands and Petrie.
Bench: Bailey and Smith.

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, L.Franklin, Didak, Pavlich, Goodes, Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench: Darling, Tapscott, C.Richardson.

MPPs are Hibberd with Heppell, Jacobs, GOD etc. Centre and Back
and mzungu and I.Smith with Prestia, Pav, Dids etc. Centre and Forward
BANK: 35K.

Hey Maca! I rated it a ,,, 8.5

Good backs, dont know much about Duigan...
Would put Watson or big Swallow prob to Boyd or Judd or Hodge...
No probs in rucks
Great forwards...
--though would try get some more cash somehouw...

[Maca24]

thanks luigi. ill prob get rid of watson for montagna..
But im very keen on andrew swallow, im sure he will do well.
im very happy with my rookies  :)

[Knowall]

dont really like that midfield.. a bit risky starting 3 rookies..

So long as you choose the right ones it is the way to go...
Last year if you had Barlow Trengrove Martin as starters with say  Bastinac and Banner or Moles on the bench you were laughing.

But how many ppl got that right very few!
Sure its great if it comes off but the rookies u think are going to play dont and that can cause major issues for ur team,  So thats why i think just play at safe