any possible changes?

[masher]

hey guys i was just wondering if you can tell me whether or not the team is good and what changes should be done?
thanks guys :D

Back line:
Brendon Goddard      
Bryce Gibbs         
Jarrad Waite      
Josh Drummond      
Chad Cornes      
Jed Adcock      
Andy Otten   

Midfield:   
Jimmy Bartel   
Marc Murphy   
Andrew Swallow      
Shaun Grigg      
David Swallow      
Nathan Foley   

Rucks:   
Aaron Sandilands      
Josh Fraser      

Forwards:
Paul Chapman      
Lance Franklin      
Nick Riewoldt      
Robert Murphy      
Ryan O'Keefe      
Drew Petrie      
Chris Knights   

Subs:   
Cameron Richardson      
Josh Toy      
Daniel Talia      
Xavier Clarke      
Tendai Mzungu      
Ian Callinan      
Joel Tippett      
Majak Daw      
Nathan Ablett      
Tom McDonald      
Luke Tapscott      

[Nails]

It's not too bad imo...

Waite and Drummong and Cornes all in the same backline = too much of a risk for mine.

Unique prems in the mids, but too unique and not strong enough imo.

Rucks aren't too shabby

Forwards look alright, not sure about ROK/Murphy though
6.5/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23855.0.html - if you don't mind rating mine please :)

[Shaggers]

It's not too bad imo...

Waite and Drummong and Cornes all in the same backline = too much of a risk for mine.

Agree with this, Waite can be great but can also be suspended for most of the season

[masher]

TEAM NAME: Caramello Koalas
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, J. Waite, J. Drummond, J. Adcock, A. Otten, B. Jacobs (C. Richardson, M. Hibberd, J. Toy)
MID: D. Swan, L. Montagna, J. Bartel, K. Jack, S. Grigg, D. Swallow (X. Clarke, T. Mzungu, I. Callinan)
RUC: A. Sandilands, J. Fraser (Z. Smith, M. Daw)
FWD: P. Chapman, L. Franklin, N. Riewoldt, R. Murphy, D. Prestia, D. Petrie, C. Knights (N. Ablett, T. McDonald, L. Tapscott)



do you guys reckon this is better or worse????

[Justin Bieber]

It's different I'll give you that ;D.

Drummo and Adcock in the same backline I don't like that much. I see Drummo as a pure SC player so maybe drop him for somebody else you like? I might add, Adcock seems more durable than Drummo (despite injuries) as he's actually played a full season before (twice and 21 games in another).

Waite is risky but if used right in the Blues lineup, could be a great pickup. Tribunal issues compared to potential upside. Depends on how you see it really.

Like the midfield premiums, Jack could be good if he continues his rise. Grigg is really unique. Could see gametime in the Tigers midfield and could be a good pickup. Although, could just be a flash in the pan. Risky choice but has room for improvement turning 23 this season.

Fraser a unique but guessing he's a cash cow? For all we know, could go back to his 2006 best but I doubt that. Still, should pull out a solid 70+ most weeks in a young lineup.