First go for a league team

[antman]

Antmans league team I'm trying to take advantage of the bye rounds and of course my rookies will change after the nab cup let me know what you think I can improve on 11900 left

Brendon Goddard       C/B   BAC   $658,600   4/14     
Brian Lake              B      BAC   $528,700   4/20     
Heath Grundy      F/B   BAC   $451,700   5/19        
Shannon Hurn      B   BAC   $427,800   5/15       
Josh Drummond      B   BAC   $416,800   4/19           
Andy Otten      B   BAC   $230,700   2/16           
Dyson Heppell      B/C   BAC   $177,500   10/24
        
Luke Hodge      C   CTR   $589,000   6/17     
Leigh Montagna      C   CTR   $580,600   4/14  
Daniel Cross      C   CTR   $576,300   4/20       
Nathan Foley      C   CTR   $283,700   11/19  
David Swallow      C   CTR   $212,500   1/9       
Andrew Gaff      C   CTR   $197,500   5/15
       
Aaron Sandilands   R   RUC   $576,500  6/16
Mark Jamar              R   RUC   $416,300   5/16
     
Paul Chapman      F/C   FWD   $588,800   6/22
Nick Riewoldt      F   FWD   $550,800   4/14   
Matthew Pavlich      C/F   FWD   $502,300   6/16   
Sam Gilbert      B/F   FWD   $468,200   4/14 
Ricky Petterd      C/F   FWD   $254,400   5/16   
Drew Petrie      R/F   FWD   $224,500   3/21
Isaac Smith      F   FWD   $122,500   6/17
   
Michael Coad      B   BAC   $87,500   1/9        
Bryce Retzlaff      B/F   BAC   $87,500   4/19      
Cameron Richardson   B   BAC   $87,500   3/21
   
Xavier Clarke      C/B   CTR   $87,500   4/19  
Andrew Krakouer   C   CTR   $87,500   7/13      
Tendai Mzungu      C/F   CTR   $87,500   6/16
       
Zac Smith              R   RUC   $87,500   1/9   
Majak Daw              F/R   RUC   $77,400   3/21
    
John Butcher      F   FWD   $87,500   12/18
Jack Darling      F   FWD   $87,500   5/15     
Luke Tapscott      F   FWD   $87,500   5/16  

[Knowall]

Lake interupted preseason so id stay away.
Jamar a bit unique but i reckon good option nevertheless.
Not sure about Grundy either, i know he did well last year but did score less as the year went on i tend to stay away from KPD.
Id pefer Boyd over Cross  or maybe  Pendles or Murphy.  If u cant afford that chuck in gibbs or Delidio as theyll have valuable MPP.

Overall decent team 8/10

[mophead222]

good backs, although i think knowall does know all, :) lake is an upgrade target coz of his preseason injury. other than that very solid and i think grundy is a nice unique. -.5

mids are ok, i deffinately think you should go hodge to swan, because i think hodge isnt as good value now that he has no MPP and is sorta inconsistant. also knowall is on the money, go cross to boyd. -1

rucks are good and i think jamar may improve again on his year last year and is a nice unique.

fowards arent bad, but i think chappy downgrade to buddy and petterd to knights, also go butcher to prestia and smith on the bench :) -.5

8/10 good job :)

can you rate my team?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23624.0.html

[Boomz]

Def: Agree with Knowall stay away from Lake & I'm unsure on Grundy wait and see what his role is.

Mid: Hodge is ok but without MPP I don't think he's good value. Montagna for mine is more of an upgrade target and I agree I'd go Boyd over Cross.

Rucks: Not sure on Jamar but he could be a bit of a unique pick & Sandi & him is a great combo as your going for league.

Fwd: Chappy won't be as good next year imo but other than that fairly good line.

8/10

[Barlow 21]

Every team must have Roo Antman so with the cash you have I`d upgrade Gilbert to Riewoldt. Gilbert is a risk seeing as he is rumoured to play forward next season which could affect his scoring greatly. He really relies on getting disposals running of the half-back line.

[mophead222]

he has him barlow /\

[Barlow 21]

Your right Mophead. :P
I`d upgrade Gilbert to Sidebottom or Didak.

[mophead222]

Your right Mophead. :P
I`d upgrade Gilbert to Sidebottom or Didak.

+1

[Knowall]

Your right Mophead. :P
I`d upgrade Gilbert to Sidebottom or Didak.

Id argue Sidebottom is hardly an ungrade.
Sylvia, Didak, Buddy good options

[Barlow 21]

Exactly correct Knowall!
Those 5 are great upgrade options from Gilbert.

[Knowall]

Exactly correct Knowall!
Those 5 are great upgrade options from Gilbert.

Lol my point is i think Gilbert will score higher than sidebottom even if he plays fwd or defence.
But theres better options around as ive stated

[Boomz]

I don't think Gilbert is a bad option with MPP and I'd say thats the main reason he has him...

[Knowall]

I don't think Gilbert is a bad option with MPP and I'd say thats the main reason he has him...

Him and Heath grundy makes sense.  But F/B MPP is worthless i wouldnt bother trade those players out and get the best possible replacements

[Boomz]

I agree in a way but i dont think its useless any MPP will help this year but don't sacrifice points because of it... Gilbert is fine imo but he has Retzlaff who is MPP already so I'd get rid of grundy.

[Barlow 21]

I agree in a way but i dont think its useless any MPP will help this year but don't sacrifice points because of it... Gilbert is fine imo but he has Retzlaff who is MPP already so I'd get rid of grundy.

Gilbert may not score as well BOOMZ which is the main concern.