The Bradman of fanplanners ;)

Started by Maca24, January 07, 2011, 07:00:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What do you think?

10
1 (11.1%)
9.5
3 (33.3%)
9
3 (33.3%)
8.5
0 (0%)
below 8
2 (22.2%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Maca24

Ok so maybe not that good  :-[ :P
Backs:
B.Gibbs, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, L.Gilbee, J.Drummond, D.Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench: Coad, Richardson, Toy.

Mids:
B.Goddard, D.Swan, J.Selwood, D.Swallow, A.Gaff, S.Atley.
Bench: Krak, Mzungu, J.Green.

Rucks:
A.Sandilands, D.Petrie.
Bench: Z.Smith, M.Bailey.

Forwards:
N.Riewoldt, L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, J.Brown, Sidebottom, C.Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench: J.Darling, A.Hooper, L.Tapscott.

I have 105K in bank.

Boomz

Backs: Very good.

Mid: Again very good Selwood is expensive though and has a bye in the finals. Would go Atley better value and should get games.

Rucks: Standard rucks for most so fine there ;)

Fwd: Very nice... Not convinced on Brown but he's a monster when fit & firing.

Overall it's very solid all round good work ;) 9/10

j959

Solid Maca - you're not worried about overall rank from memory, are you?

same concerns as Boomz about Browny but sometimes you just have to do it. I'm coming around to the Sandi/Petrie ruck combo cos it actually lets you put the money elsewhere.

Atley v Conca - not sure til closer to Rd1 but what I would get you to consider is that Atley's byes will be Rd3 & Rd21, whereas Conca's will be Rd11 & Rd19 - Conca will allow for more cash cow accumulation til byes and Atley if you keep him won't play the Qual final for you.

Barlow 21

Good Solid Team 9/10
I`d definetly look at Conca ahead of Atley if possible.

P.S: (The catchy thread name attracted me. :P)

Maca24

#4
Quote from: j959 on January 07, 2011, 08:21:29 PM
Solid Maca - you're not worried about overall rank from memory, are you?

same concerns as Boomz about Browny but sometimes you just have to do it. I'm coming around to the Sandi/Petrie ruck combo cos it actually lets you put the money elsewhere.

Atley v Conca - not sure til closer to Rd1 but what I would get you to consider is that Atley's byes will be Rd3 & Rd21, whereas Conca's will be Rd11 & Rd19 - Conca will allow for more cash cow accumulation til byes and Atley if you keep him won't play the Qual final for you.
cheers guys. not as good as my other team but im trying :)
Yea browny is just a question on whether he is fit or not.
also im hoping he fires without fev (assuming he gets sacked)
Ok ill go with atley i think. j959 nar rank doesnt bother me, just a bonus :)

Barlow 21

All your teams are really pretty strong Maca.

Maca24


Total Tiger

Conca isn't a bad option but i would get Atley because i don't think Conca will get heaps of midfield time like Martin did last year because of the recent inclusions of Grigg and Houli plus he had ankle surgery just before the draft and isn't fully fit yet.

Total Tiger


Maca24

thanks TT for the article. will have2 watch him i guess.  :)

Barlow 21

Nice Find TT!
I will be watching Conca carefully over Pre-Season. 8)

Hawka

awesome team
derserves a 9/10 but il say
9.94/10 ;)

Maca24


mophead222

fantastic team as what i would expect from you maca,

only query is no otten?

and you could swap tapscott for tom mcdonald and have mpp with drew petrie.  :)

9.8/10

Barlow 21

Otten is no lock for me either Mophead. He may have the same average as a rookie who will be way cheaper. ;)