HELPPLEASE (:

azza_tash · January 06, 2011, 10:31:33 PM

I do supercoach every year, but don't pay much attention, as i feel the scoring is too inconsistent and unpredictable.. But i wanna give a good go this year, so a lot of help would be appreciated, heres my team:

Backs:
Brendon Goddard C/B
Bryce Gibbs B/C
Brett Deledio C/B
Sam Gilbert B/F
Jed Adcock B
Andy Otten B
Ben Jacobs B

Bench:
Sam Iles B
Cameron Richardson B
Josh Toy B

Midfield:
Luke Hodge C
Alan Didak F/C
Jimmy Bartel C
Brock McLean C
David Swallow C
Andrew Gaff C

Aaron Sandilands R
Dean Cox R RUC

Paul Chapman F/C
Nick Riewoldt F
Adam Goodes F/C
Robert Murphy F/B
Ricky Petterd C/F
Chris Knights F
Drew Petrie R/F

Dyson Heppell B/C
Andrew Krakouer C
Tendai Mzungu C/B
Zac Smith R
Majak Daw F/R
Isaac Smith F
Dion Prestia F
Lewis Johnston F

Couldn't be bothererd putting the rest of the bench in position, but you get the picture

bomberboy0618 · January 06, 2011, 10:33:24 PM

hmm :-\
no mclean, lewis johnston ???
murphy is inconsistent, 2 gc bb, 6.5/10, needs a major overhaul

azza_tash · January 06, 2011, 10:47:18 PM

well mclean.. was a gun, if he can regain up to half of his best he'll be a great cash cow.. lewis johnston is a former 1st round draft pick, and is quite fit and training well, and murphy tore it to shreads finals last year playing across half back, so if he goes back to that role he'll hopefully even be a keeper, and i can't see any more suitable MPP for the backline than him..

bomberboy0618 · January 06, 2011, 10:52:08 PM

murphy stats:
average:71.1
scores range from 130-19 (injured) 130-38 (not)

azza_tash · January 06, 2011, 11:01:50 PM

haha, i don't care what happened last year, its a new year i think he'll go alright

Gooner · January 07, 2011, 01:20:48 PM

Backline is good as are the rucks. It's just a question as to how many games Daw gets.

I think Dids and Bartel could be better upgrade targets, Chappy won't match last year as he's likely to suffer more injuries and a harder tag with no GAJ.

bjrouse · January 07, 2011, 01:42:39 PM

Not the team I would want but we can't all have the same sides.
I give it 6-7/10 as I feel you have made about that percentage in decent decisions

azza_tash · January 07, 2011, 07:37:10 PM

thanks for the comments, bj i have daw there to switch with petrie if need be, don't really expect him to get a game.. and didak is there to switch in the forward line, but as i said i'm not really too experienced with the supercoach strategies and what not, so suggestions for another c/f would be great (: and same goes for bartel, only picked him because i love him as a dter haha

Knowall · January 08, 2011, 12:39:08 AM

I think its decent backline is very decent and same with the mids. I dont mind Mclean although i think theres better midpricers. Rucks are both guns and Forward line is a bit iffy take Murphy out hes older and more injury prone better options available. Possibly Pettard, Knights, Petrie is too risky

Ill give it a 7 just fix up that fwd line maybe take some money out of other positions

Master Q · January 08, 2011, 02:20:38 PM

Not sure if you should take Robert Murphy. And I'm not a fan of Mclean.

azza_tash · January 08, 2011, 05:53:22 PM

Backs:
Brendon Goddard C/B
Bryce Gibbs B/C
Brett Deledio C/B
Sam Gilbert B/F
Jed Adcock B
Andy Otten B
Ben Jacobs B

Bench:
Sam Iles B
Cameron Richardson B
Josh Toy B

Midfield:
Luke Hodge C
Chris Judd C
Dane Swan C
Brock McLean C
David Swallow C
Andrew Gaff C
Dyson Heppell B/C
Andrew Krakouer C
Tendai Mzungu C/B

Aaron Sandilands R
Dean Cox R RUC
Zac Smith R
Majak Daw F/R

Paul Chapman F/C
Nick Riewoldt F
Adam Goodes F/C
Ricky Petterd C/F
Chris Knights F
Drew Petrie R/F
Dion Prestia

Isaac Smith F
Bryce Retzlaff F
Jack Darling F

any better?

mophead222 · January 08, 2011, 06:19:11 PM

Quote from: azza_tash on January 06, 2011, 10:31:33 PM
I do supercoach every year, but don't pay much attention, as i feel the scoring is too inconsistent and unpredictable.. But i wanna give a good go this year, so a lot of help would be appreciated, heres my team:

Backs:
Brendon Goddard C/B
Bryce Gibbs B/C
Brett Deledio C/B
Sam Gilbert B/F
Jed Adcock B
Andy Otten B
Ben Jacobs B

Bench:
Sam Iles B
Cameron Richardson B
Josh Toy B

Midfield:
Luke Hodge C
Alan Didak F/C
Jimmy Bartel C
Brock McLean C
David Swallow C
Andrew Gaff C

Aaron Sandilands R
Dean Cox R RUC

Paul Chapman F/C
Nick Riewoldt F
Adam Goodes F/C
Robert Murphy F/B
Ricky Petterd C/F
Chris Knights F
Drew Petrie R/F

Dyson Heppell B/C
Andrew Krakouer C
Tendai Mzungu C/B
Zac Smith R
Majak Daw F/R
Isaac Smith F
Dion Prestia F
Lewis Johnston F

Couldn't be bothererd putting the rest of the bench in position, but you get the picture

Backs are rock solid although i prefer drummond over adcock :)

Sorry but i rekon your mids are poor. hodge imo is not worth that huge pricetag with no mpp and for a super prem he is sorta inconsistant, bartel is sorta unknown how he will go with not ablett, so risky there, brock mclean (NO), imo drop mclean and move heppell into starter, and swap bartel for swan. and get josh green for your bench -1.5

rucks good although i rekon cox wont be as good as last year as WC will wanna start moving naitanui into the no1 ruck role coz he is the future. -.5

dont like bob murphy but other than that good, lewis johnston ????? should swap for a B/F who can swap with gilbert. -1

overall 7.5/10

sorrry for being a little harsh but just my opinion :)

can u rate my team ?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23624.0.html

azza_tash · January 08, 2011, 07:02:12 PM

haha, if you rate my new team, a comment above yours :P

mophead222 · January 08, 2011, 08:00:48 PM

update your first post, as not to confuse people. :)

only thing i dont like is cox, and hodge and mclean. other than that. very good

9.2/10 :)

TOM15 · January 08, 2011, 08:09:24 PM

i would probably swap mclean for Anthony who is a great mid-pricer who is a really reliable midfielder and mega cash cow