To Welsh Or Not To Welsh: 2011

Started by Alex7089, December 31, 2010, 11:09:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Locking In Welsh for 2011?

Hell yes, who wouldn't?!?
0 (0%)
Maybe, he's on my shortlist.
0 (0%)
We'll see how his pre-season goes.
3 (23.1%)
Unlikely
6 (46.2%)
HELL NO!
4 (30.8%)

Total Members Voted: 4

Alex7089

Andrew Welsh
2010 Stats
Games: 11
Average: 72.64
High Score: 136 (Round 11)
Low Score: 42 (Round 4)
High Price: 421,200    
Low Price: 333,800    
Starting Price: 421,200    
Rank: 347
Career Stats
Games: 149
Debut: Round 7, 2002.
Average: 80.0625
Pick: 47, 2001.
Crystal Ball
2011 Price: $304,100
Position: Midfield
Summary
Andrew Welsh is a very good player, a career average of 80 is pretty good, but he is 27, and he'll be 28 in February. So he is getting old, and after an injury riddled 2010 season who knows how much footy he'll play in 2011. He comes at an awkward price, but, he can break games open and score 130+, and with a good pre-season he may be able to return to the form of 05/08. If he could, he would be very good value, if not, he could burn you.
Alex's Choice
No for me. Flat out, there are to many good options in the midfield to be picking a guy who is still low on confidence from a very unfortunate injury early last year.

ossie85


An interesting prospect :) I don't have the balls to pick him, but I like the uniqueness!

Fletch74

Unlikely, too much of a tagger. Won't do enough in SC.

ronl

In fairness to some of these Essendon blokes, under the Knights regime alot of them probably didn't know if they were coming or going or what the hell was going on half of the time.  It would pay to keep an eye on this guy's pre-season form, I think.

j959

thanks for the write-up Alex.

think you nailed it on the head about his awkward price, better midfield options and Fletch's 'tagger' warning ... good to keep an eye on these sorts of options though ... can you get mid-pricer 'bubble boys'??  ;)

Boomz

used to love him but tbh i think he's past it... he's not that old though. Unlikely.

MajorLazer

An Essendon player? Forget it. :P

Very unlikely for me. Hadn't come under any consideration either.

Junktimer


nas


MTTY

I would much rather pick Stants or Watson before him

Hawka

Quote from: MTTY on January 19, 2011, 11:45:01 PM
I would much rather pick Stants or Watson before him
same but i doubt i will pick those ppl ever ::)

dylsta05

could be handy at that price but unlikley

Alex7089

Quote from: hawka26 on January 24, 2011, 11:55:18 AM
Quote from: MTTY on January 19, 2011, 11:45:01 PM
I would much rather pick Stants or Watson before him
same but i doubt i will pick those ppl ever ::)
Don't knock Watson, I had him last year and he did quite well for me :-*
Stanton is another story, he won't come near my SC, ever.

---------------
Come and vote for the Personality of the Year!
FF is a big place, show your support to some of the big names.
Every vote counts!

MTTY

Quote from: Alex7089 on January 25, 2011, 11:32:42 AM
Quote from: hawka26 on January 24, 2011, 11:55:18 AM
Quote from: MTTY on January 19, 2011, 11:45:01 PM
I would much rather pick Stants or Watson before him
same but i doubt i will pick those ppl ever ::)
Don't knock Watson, I had him last year and he did quite well for me :-*
Stanton is another story, he won't come near my SC, ever.

---------------
Come and vote for the Personality of the Year!
FF is a big place, show your support to some of the big names.
Every vote counts!
Had Watson as well was a very consistent scorer

antman