James Kelly

[Junktimer]

lids could come in for the duffman or bock, not sure who.  it looks pretty good anyway

[elephants]

thanks jt :)

[MiGZ]

i think lids has to be a lock in the backline as much as goddard is. he is goign to give a 90 average at the worst, and had a 97 average 2 years back. with an emerging midfield he is goign to get help wherever he plays. if your tossing up between kelly/bock and deledio...its a no brainer for mine.

[elephants]

do you think that lids will handle the tag he receives?

i have some battles in my backs at the moment too

TWO OF
kelly/bock/lids

ONE OF
houli/otten/s.selwwod

[Junktimer]

kelly/lids

otten

my 2 cents.

[elephants]

great thanks jt
i would say 5 :)

[McRooster]

I will start with Deledio and upgrade another to Goddard at some stage.

Bock I'd stay away from, only once in 7 seasons has he played all 22 - very injury prone. Even in his best DT ave season of 2009 he only played 14 games for an average of 87.8 - and at his price he's more of a keeper, doubling the risk.
Will play more of a General type role at GC, directing the play out of defence and allowing others to do the run, carry and kick that he used to.
Spent most of 2010 in a moon boot.

Kelly I'm still unsure, maybe Gibbs or Scotland instead to soften the spread of teams.

[Junktimer]

Bock I'd stay away from, only once in 7 seasons has he played all 22 - very injury prone. Even in his best DT ave season of 2009 he only played 14 games for an average of 87.8 - and at his price he's more of a keeper, doubling the risk.
Will play more of a General type role at GC, directing the play out of defence and allowing others to do the run, carry and kick that he used to.
Spent most of 2010 in a moon boot.

sure its not your love of the Crows which says no to the "traitor"  ;)

[McRooster]

Bock I'd stay away from, only once in 7 seasons has he played all 22 - very injury prone. Even in his best DT ave season of 2009 he only played 14 games for an average of 87.8 - and at his price he's more of a keeper, doubling the risk.
Will play more of a General type role at GC, directing the play out of defence and allowing others to do the run, carry and kick that he used to.
Spent most of 2010 in a moon boot.

sure its not your love of the Crows which says no to the "traitor"  ;)

DT is a numbers game and numbers don't lie.
I also don't lie and will freely admit I think personally he's a spud, who skulked around behind his mates backs, slapped his GF and didn't raise his head around Adelaide for some time- preferring to hide in the shadows and strike from the DARK SIDE.
I am in a way happy about his departure as it does ensure the survival of one of my Rooster fav's Phil Davis and him taking that role, allowing the returning Ottens to run forward in the role Craig had Ottens destined to do before he did his knee.

[elephants]

hahah i will admit i did think that at first too jt but rooster as usual makes some very very valid points :)
i was always cinsidering gibbsy but for some reason he is not in my team? maybe due to his inconsistency? anyway i am not overly sold on bock now (thanks to rooster haha) so i am thinking maybe bock ----------> another premium i.e lids, gibbs, scotsman :)

[valkorum]

hahah i will admit i did think that at first too jt but rooster as usual makes some very very valid points :)
i was always cinsidering gibbsy but for some reason he is not in my team? maybe due to his inconsistency? anyway i am not overly sold on bock now (thanks to rooster haha) so i am thinking maybe bock ----------> another premium i.e lids, gibbs, scotsman :)

Any of those 3 I think are better than Bock

[elephants]

hahah i will admit i did think that at first too jt but rooster as usual makes some very very valid points :)
i was always cinsidering gibbsy but for some reason he is not in my team? maybe due to his inconsistency? anyway i am not overly sold on bock now (thanks to rooster haha) so i am thinking maybe bock ----------> another premium i.e lids, gibbs, scotsman :)

Any of those 3 I think are better than Bock

yeah thanks valk i suppose i though bock was a good unique but now i know why he has been steered clear of hah, i cant really choose but at the moment maybe lids :)

[nas]

Lids first Gibbs 2nd or both. IMO

[MajorLazer]

Go for Deledio. I can see him scoring more than Gibbs and Scotland.

[elephants]

yep and lids is a lot younger than scotland too :)