Best Players of All time

[Master Q]

JT you realise that there's a huge chance someone from Collingwoood or Essendon will win as they have the most supporters on FF  ???

[ossie85]

JT you realise that there's a huge chance someone from Collingwoood or Essendon will win as they have the most supporters on FF  ???

So do Carlton :)

Don't worry, I'll be unbias at least! The other Pies are fairly premium also.

Those Essendon guys are a bit shifty though.

[Alex7089]

We try :'(

[Junktimer]

Yeah I know Q, I'm just hoping for unbiased votes and common a
sense will be implemented.  I know that a magpie has a much better chance than say a powerman purely because of the club he played for though

[nas]

Yeah I know Q, I'm just hoping for unbiased votes and common a
sense will be implemented.  I know that a magpie has a much better chance than say a powerman purely because of the club he played for though

What say a power person is ex of another club example Wangas? > Ex Ess

[DazBurg]

Yeah I know Q, I'm just hoping for unbiased votes and common a
sense will be implemented.  I know that a magpie has a much better chance than say a powerman purely because of the club he played for though

What say a power person is ex of another club example Wangas? > Ex Ess

thats a good point great player at both clubs
played more games at power but did win a brownlow at the bombers so that is tough

[DazBurg]

well they actually have this sort of thing already done at essendon website

http://www.essendonfc.com.au/champions/

[nas]

Yeah I know Q, I'm just hoping for unbiased votes and common a
sense will be implemented.  I know that a magpie has a much better chance than say a powerman purely because of the club he played for though

What say a power person is ex of another club example Wangas? > Ex Ess

thats a good point great player at both clubs
played more games at power but did win a brownlow at the bombers so that is tough

my point exactly as there is others in the mix say > Primus / Pickett / just to make it 3 of for examples

[DazBurg]

Yeah I know Q, I'm just hoping for unbiased votes and common a
sense will be implemented.  I know that a magpie has a much better chance than say a powerman purely because of the club he played for though

What say a power person is ex of another club example Wangas? > Ex Ess

thats a good point great player at both clubs
played more games at power but did win a brownlow at the bombers so that is tough

my point exactly as there is others in the mix say > Primus / Pickett / just to make it 3 of for examples

well Primus would easily be port at Fitzroy he was only young
but pickett is a tougher one

[nas]

Pickett 3 clubs

[DazBurg]

Pickett 3 clubs

true though he did win a norm smith at port maybe that could decide it
or maybe he could be nominated in all clubs doubt he'd win in any of them either way

[nas]

Dew? Turn into a favorite at the Hawks also.

Hardwick another ex  Ess

[Barlow 21]

We could vote for the best Bomber out of that list of Champions on their site.

[Cicjose]

I thought of an idea today.

Over the next few weeks, I'm thinking of opening up threads on each club board with a poll, asking the simple question: Who is the best player to ever play for that club?

At the end, on the AFL board, we will vote who is the best player from those 16 players.

I would be interested to hear what you guys think about it.

For example, should there be nominations here in this thread, or should I just make them using my discretion and somebody can vote for them if I leave them out?

I just think it would be a fun and interesting thing to do.

Let me know what you think.

Cheers, JT

Decided so far:
Mark Ricciuto

Nominations underway for the Lions:

There is no way Ricciuto is better than Mccleod :(

[CrowsFan]

Are you on crack CJ???
That is the only reason I can think of for why you just said that!