New team :D

[bomberboy0618]

Plz rate out of 10 and why.
BACKS
Brendon Goddard (Mid),  Bryce Gibbs (Mid),  Brett Deledio (Mid),  James Kelly (Mid),  Andy Otten,  Jed Adcock ,  Tendai Mzungu
BB
Bryce Retzlaff (Fwd), Cameron Richardson, Josh Toy
MIDS
Dane Swan,  Matthew Boyd, Andrew Swallow, Reece Conca, David Swallow, Andrew Gaff
MB
Ian Callinan (Fwd),  Dyson Heppell (Mid), Andrew Krakouer
RUCKS
Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB
Tom Derickx, Zac Smith    
FORWARDS
Nick Riewoldt , Cyril Rioli,  Matthew Pavlich (Mid),  Steele Sidebottom (Mid),  Jonathan Brown, Dion Prestia,  Isaac Smith     
FB
Brandon Matera,  Daniel Talia (Def),  Dylan McNeil (Mid)   
Rate and post a link and ill rate yours :)
I have 97.4k in the bank

[ossie85]

I count 6 rookies + Otten as starting! A little too weak for my liking BB. 7/10

Downgrade a MID or RUC IMO

[MTTY]

1.I too think you have one too many rookies starting in the backs maybe upgrade one to Adcock

2.I don't think Hallahan will play much in 2011

3.Higgins may be a risk but could come of if he sorts his injuries out.

pretty good team 8.5/10

[bomberboy0618]

updated :)

[tferrier18]

Dude your team is almost impossible to read

[nas]

What a (sorry BB) wasted lengthy post. Would have been better as a team position layout.

[bomberboy0618]

Guys I'll fix it tonight :)

[pyronerd]

What a (sorry BB) wasted lengthy post. Would have been better as a team position layout.

sorry BB but i agree, also u seem to have a lot of MPPs but they are all sitting in either B or F so u cant use them, i would maybe think of rearranging a bit to accommodate

[Junktimer]

Plz rate out of 10 and why.
BACKS
Goddard, Brendon (Mid)
Gibbs, Bryce (Mid)
Deledio, Brett (Mid)
Gilbee, Lindsay (Mid)
Otten, Andy
Jed Adcock
Mzungu, Tendai
BB
Puopolo, Paul
Richardson, Cameron
Toy, Josh
MIDS
Swan, Dane   
Montagna, Leigh   
Bartel, Jimmy   
Anthony, Liam   
Swallow, David   
Gaff, Andrew   
MB
Blease, Sam   
Shaun Atley
Krakouer, Andrew   
RUCKS
Sandilands, Aaron   
Jolly, Darren   
RB
Derickx, Tom   
Smith, Zac   
FORWARDS
Riewoldt, Nick      
Rioli, Cyril      
Pavlich, Matthew (Mid)      
Sidebottom, Steele (Mid)      
Higgins, Shaun (Mid)      
Prestia, Dion      
Smith, Isaac      
FB
Matera, Brandon   
Tapscott, Luke   
McNeil, Dylan (Mid)   
Rate and post a link and ill rate yours :)
I have 41,900 in the bank

hey BB

backs: not too sure on gilbee, is a good SC player  but I had him this year and he is quite inconsistent.  I think James Kelly is a much better option.  -0.5

mids: not sold on montagna or bartel.  Both have high scoring potential, but you can have more consistent players such as boyd or cross or swallow instead, i think they are better options.  -1

rucks: fine.

fwds: dont like higgins, he is made of butter.  id be much more inclined to save money and get knights. -0.5

Overall, I think you may have too many rookies starting, in spite of this though, I don't think you have enough premiums either, few too many mid pricers.  Bit of tweaking will fix this.

Nice team, 8/10

can you rate my updated team?

[ChrisWog97]

well BB you could have made it a bit neater but besides that your team is decent. the updates you made on i agree with.
8.5/10 good job man!

[bomberboy0618]

fixed and updated.

[pyronerd]

u still don't have any MPPs in the midfield, so all your B/M and M/F MPPs lose their effectiveness

[bomberboy0618]

u still don't have any MPPs in the midfield, so all your B/M and M/F MPPs lose their effectiveness

ill do it later ;)

[Barlow 21]

u still don't have any MPPs in the midfield, so all your B/M and M/F MPPs lose their effectiveness

Easy to place a rookie as MPP with your players in Backs/Fwds.

[bomberboy0618]

u still don't have any MPPs in the midfield, so all your B/M and M/F MPPs lose their effectiveness

Easy to place a rookie as MPP with your players in Backs/Fwds.

ah ok, rate?