Iles or Hibberd?

[erich1036]

My defence bench at the moment is cameron richardson and josh toy with tendai mzungu on the field. the last position on my defence bench is between iles and hibberd and i was wondering who you guys thought would get the most games and which one would have the greater scoring capabilities. thanks.

[Boomz]

For me I have both but I think Iles will be a better option as he is almost a certainty to play where as Hibberd isn't...

[tferrier18]

I'd go with Isles. Has afl experience and is a hard runner which is always very beneficial

[erich1036]

Its looking like i will go iles. thanks guys.

[Junktimer]

Iles for me.  better still Michael Coad, IMO

[erich1036]

I reckon iles has the ability to score more heavily than coad playing as a more half back/back pocket player opposed to coad strictly being a key defender. especially as bock the other key defender will rack up a lot of points.

[Junktimer]

thats a good point, but Michael Coad's stats in the SANFL are ultra impressive.

Iles tried once at AFL level and failed, what makes everyone think he'll make it this time?

[erich1036]

in the vfl this year sam iles played 18 games to be named in the best 11 times. michael coad played 8 games to named in the best 4 times. i cant find iles vfl stats anywhere but coad averaged 20 disposals and 7 marks last year, a great return for a key defender.

[Junktimer]

coad played 13 games this year though.  either would be fine though

[LiveTheDream]

Iles for me.  better still Michael Coad, IMO

+1

[Hawka]

iles by a mile