Good or Bad? - DT version

Started by Boomz, December 26, 2010, 04:45:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Boomz

Defence: Goddard(M), Gibbs(M), Deledio(M), Kelly(M), Duffield, Mzungu, Richardson (Iles, Hibberd, Toy)

Midfield: Swan, Selwood, K. Cornes, D. Swallow, Heppell(D), Atley (Krakouer, Green, Callinan(F)

Ruck: Sandilands, Petrie(F) (Smith, Jenkins)

Forward: Franklin, Sylvia(M), Thomas, Riewoldt, Chapman(M), Knights, Darling (Smith, Dixon, McDonald(R)

159k left over rookies all subject to change. Rate and feedback appreciated :) will rate yours too if u post the link. Cheers.

JarrydBlair

Backs are strong, no need to change them.
Midfield is pretty good. Like that you got Cornes. Not many people will get him and he is a proven gun.
Rucks are the same as almost everyones but you can't go wrong with those guys.
Forwards are strong as well.
You have 159k  but at this point I would hang onto it because your side doesn't really need change.

8/10.

Boomz

Cheers JB :P

I like Cornes and have had him before and he never really lets u down which is great. Only player I'm not convinced on is Chapman but not sure who I'd replace him with so he stays for now.


popedelio

i wouldn't change it seems like a very good team, see if you could get Anthony in your midfield, thats all i can say, though this will kill all you cash. Or go with this team but not get very close overall because of 3 starting rookies.

Boomz

I like Anthony as a player but I don't like him as DTer and have my doubts. He's been good but has only played 17 games... If he plays a full season I don't think he'll be up to scratch so may as well go with a rookie. If I upgrade them at the right time then I reckon I can still get close overall... If u trade well anything can happen ;) Cheers though :)

popedelio

I agree, though Anthony is a DTer, hes not so much SC because of some incorrect disposals, but the kid racks up the possies and the stats, meaning good DTer. I only mentioned Anthony for the fact that he is a lil cheaper and you don't have to make many changes to your team to be able to afford him. He has potential to become a great DTer if  he plays games,because hes already a consistent scorer, just not durable.

Boomz

Yeah but I don't think you can say he is a consistent scorer going off 17 games in 2 seasons... Thats what I'm getting at if he plays a full season teams will work him out... He's at a nice price but it's just what I think ur not wrong either he could be a great buy...

PowerMan

Quote from: BOOMZ on December 26, 2010, 04:45:05 PM
Defence: Goddard(M), Gibbs(M), Deledio(M), Kelly(M), Duffield, Mzungu, Richardson (Iles, Hibberd, Toy)

Midfield: Swan, Selwood, K. Cornes, D. Swallow, Heppell(D), Atley (Krakouer, Green, Callinan(F)

Ruck: Sandilands, Petrie(F) (Smith, Jenkins)

Forward: Franklin, Sylvia(M), Thomas, Riewoldt, Chapman(M), Knights, Darling (Smith, Dixon, McDonald(R)

159k left over rookies all subject to change. Rate and feedback appreciated :) will rate yours too if u post the link. Cheers.

very solid all over the park, 8.5/10!

Boomz


elephants

i like it BOOMZ, kane oornes is a player that will offer you 90-110 points per game proven gun :D

not a fan of dale thomes to be honest, he will have more compettition for a mid spot next year with the introduction of kraks :D also chappy is, well lets face it, getting on a bit and gazza leaving could hurt OR help his scores. more space to roam without gazz but more likely to cop a tag :D

Boomz

Cheers :D

I like Thomas but that's a fair point... Will wait & see pre-season. Chappy is the main player I'm definitely not set on but not sure who to replace him with at this stage but he'll be gone by the start of the season ;)

popedelio

I disagree, thomas is still going to play well, and i'm pretty sure kraks is going to play more foward then midfield, and thomas kinda plays like the sweeper in the half back area