Polec, Conca or Caddy?

Started by brownyyy, December 26, 2010, 03:31:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

brownyyy

one vacant spot on my midfield bench. options are reece conca, josh caddy or jared polec?   which option looks the best????

Boomz

Depends... All should play but I'd probably go Conca as he'll likely be F/C so more flexibility.

Junktimer

conca for me.  especially as he should be FWD/MID

but i think gaff is better than them all.

brownyyy

yea Gaff is a jet. already on my team

brownyyy

tough call between caddy and conca, both inside midfielders. i reckon conca, but. by a small margin. polec wont do much for ya imo

elephants

what is peoples beef with polec? not much talk of him around the place?

dale93

What's the price of all of them?

Junktimer

elephants i think its because he is like stephen hill in the respect that he drifts in and out of games.  unlike gaff and caddy who are good consistent performers.

Dale the prices are:

Polec: $168,200
Conca: $164,200
Caddy: $160,200

Based on m0nty's fanplanner

Barlow 21


Junktimer

caddy has just undergone surgery so that pretty much rules him out

Barlow 21

Quote from: Junktimer on December 28, 2010, 10:26:04 AM
caddy has just undergone surgery so that pretty much rules him out
I know. He was a lock before I heard that. ::)

Holz

polec for me, brisbane has lost alot of players, so he should play most games and someone has to get posessions on the team

Barlow 21

Quote from: Holzman on December 28, 2010, 08:22:46 PM
polec for me, brisbane has lost alot of players, so he should play most games and someone has to get posessions on the team
He will get games but may not score as well as Conca IMO.

SydneyRox

I am looking at Conca as well, so of these three he is my pick.

Joshy11

How long is the lay off for caddy?