Buddy vs. Cyril

[ossie85]

Buddy for me - he had a very underrated year last year. Rioli's exciting, but until he eliminates some of that inconsistency I'll wait a bit

[SydneyRox]

Will Buddys apparant move into the midfield help his scores? How long will it take him to get used to the idea? and start having an effect?
I think Buddy is the one too, but preseason watch on Cyril is what I will be doing

[Hawka]

well with hale now buddy can move to the midfeild and remember it didnt take leading fwds like richo and pav long

[ossie85]

Buddy in the midfield is very, very enticing. Should mean less low scores

[Maca24]

Both will be great options. cant split them yet.
buddy will kill it and cyril will to IMO. im considering both.

[nas]

Would myself go for Buddy.

[Alex7089]

Depends With both looking at mid time it is really really hard. Both can have shockers, but for me, the difference is, Buddy can also pull out 150+ scores when he gets going.

I hate inconsistency, and it is hard to be consistent in the forward pocket/FF, so I will be watching both in the NAB cup to see how they go in the middle.

[Torress]

it really is one or the other isn't it? or is it? hey they both have fantasy sex appeal no doubts. We'll see how their pre season pans out for starters. whats buddy price, fairly pricey and cyril is a better price. but buddy has a bigger ceiling... it is a really tough decision. but buddy with a big pre season - how the fire truck do u ignore him? esp with him roaming up the ground like richo and kicking ass when he is in the F50. had cyril in my fanplanner since day dot, would feel comfortable starting buddy too. but could u do both?? maybe and a big maybe if cyril is mpp

[Boomz]

I have rioli atm but Buddy is certainly very very tempting... have the cash too.. hmmm

[MajorLazer]

It is very hard to figure out. I am hoping Buddy has some low scores in the first rounds, then I can pick him up cheaper. I may start with both.

Rioli is near lock and will be if he's MPP.

[bomberboy0618]

im going delicious.

[Alex7089]

It is very hard to figure out. I am hoping Buddy has some low scores in the first rounds, then I can pick him up cheaper. I may start with both.

Rioli is near lock and will be if he's MPP.

Ah, the GAJ approach, from memory this had many in tears after 5-10 rounds :P

it really is one or the other isn't it? or is it? hey they both have fantasy sex appeal no doubts. We'll see how their pre season pans out for starters. whats buddy price, fairly pricey and cyril is a better price. but buddy has a bigger ceiling... it is a really tough decision. but buddy with a big pre season - how the fire truck do u ignore him? esp with him roaming up the ground like richo and kicking ass when he is in the F50. had cyril in my fanplanner since day dot, would feel comfortable starting buddy too. but could u do both?? maybe and a big maybe if cyril is mpp

You are right I suppose, there are only 17 teams and we have to pick 30 so we have two from some teams, and if Cyril is MPP he can simply be moved to the midfield and covered by a rookie given byes/injuries.

So, upon second thought it is quite possible to have both ;)

[bomberboy0618]

its actually 33  ;D

[nas]

A lot awaiting Cyril's magic word for MPP > IF

[MajorLazer]

A lot awaiting Cyril's magic word for MPP > IF

If it happens, he and Buddy will make my team.