Macdoga's Mob V3: EDITED :)

[Maca24]

Here is version 3.  :P
Backs
B.Gibbs, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, S.Gilbert, J.Drummond, D.Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench. T.Mzungu, C.Richardson, J.Toy.

Mids
B.Goddard, D.Swan, A.Swallow, D.Swallow, A.Gaff, S.Atley.
Bench. J.Green, A.Krakouer, M.Hallahan.

Rucks
A.Sandilands, D.Petrie.
Bench. M.Bailey and T.Derickx.

Forwards
N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, J.Brown, C.Rioli, J.Waite, Sidebottom, D.Prestia.
Bench. J.Darling, A.Hooper, L.Tapscott.

Thanks guys, plz rate ill rate your team if i havent already  ;)
Should only need to upgrade 7 players :)

[Junktimer]

Here is version 3.  :P
Backs
L.Hodge, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, J.Kelly, A.Otten, D.Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench. T.Mzungu, C.Richardson, J.Toy.

Mids
B.Goddard, D.Swan, M.Murphy, D.Swallow, A.Gaff, S.Atley.
Bench. J.Green, A.Krakouer, D.McNeil.

Rucks
A.Sandilands, D.Jolly.
Bench. M.Bailey and Z.Smith.

Forwards
P.Chapman, N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, C.Rioli, Sidebottom, C.Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench. J.Darling, A.Hooper, L.Tapscott.

Thanks guys, plz rate ill rate your team if i havent already  ;)

hey maca,

backs: strong backline, no problems there.

mids: not sure about murph.  bye in round 23, and very expensive, maybe andy swallow or boydo could be a better option. -0.5

rucks: no problems.

fwds: no problems.

sorry about the lack of feedback, its a really strong team!

very nice team, 9.5/10

can you rate my updated team?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html

[MajorLazer]

I really like the team. No lines look weaker than any other. 9.714367/10. ;D

Team looks like what I am trying to form and I may have, but don't want to post it just in case it's copied.

[Maca24]

haha thanks ML. have stacked my backline in all the fanplanners so i wanted to try something different.
Junky, i am considering murphy cas he is consistent and should improve. also the bye doesnt faze me lol. but yes andy swallow and Jack are in my plans to.

[Junktimer]

I really like the team. No lines look weaker than any other. 9.69/10. ;D

Team looks like what I am trying to form and I may have, but don't want to post it just in case it's copied.

so indie major

[MajorLazer]

I really like the team. No lines look weaker than any other. 9.69/10. ;D

Team looks like what I am trying to form and I may have, but don't want to post it just in case it's copied.

so indie major

I'll change it just for you Junk. :P

[pyronerd]

ill give it a 9.5/10 i cant see really any flaws in the team, the .5 off was for when you beat me next year  :P

[Lippa]

I give it an 8.5/10.
Backs : very good
Mids : may be left a bit short with bench if atley does play enough and gaff
Rucks : Nice
Forwards : Nice as well

[Maca24]

fair enough i guess lippa. thanks pyro  :)

[Luigi197]

Hey Maca; 9/10 for V3 from me :D

BACKS: Look good though I've always been a bit hesitant towards Kelly IMO' idk why, he just doesnt seem to pull big numbers when he's versing top-order teams and when Geelong need him most. He's a great players, dont get me wrong, i just wouldnt put him in my team ATM unless convinced otherwise... Havent everyone been saying that Hodge will be just a MID nxt year? In that case u wud sub in Gibbs if he's moving to the BAC nxt year.
MIDS: Look good though haven't heard much about this "J.Green"... Is he good? And i would be a bit hesitant about 3 starting rookies...
RUCKS: KK OK
FWDS: Real good!


Luigi :D

[Maca24]

yes luigi im praying gibbs is MPP, he should be IMO.
If he he is then kelly goes out and gibbs comes in. but for the moment I like kelly. and 3 starting rookies is the way2 go  ::) lol. foley just doesnt interest me, id rather make more cash with a rookie and save some cash also. thanks for the feedback  :)

[Maca24]

Just made an edit. also a question on which combo.
Buddy and I.Smith or Rioli and Prestia?
im leaning towards buddy and smith..

[Junktimer]

rioli and prestia for me

[Boomz]

Here is version 3.  :P
Backs
B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, A.Otten, D.Heppell, B.Jacobs.
Bench. T.Mzungu, C.Richardson, J.Toy.

Mids
D.Swan, L.Montagna, A.Swallow, D.Swallow, A.Gaff, S.Atley.
Bench. J.Green, A.Krakouer, M.Hallahan.

Rucks
A.Sandilands, D.Jolly.
Bench. M.Bailey and Z.Smith.

Forwards
P.Chapman, N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, C.Rioli, Sidebottom, C.Knights, D.Prestia.
Bench. J.Darling, A.Hooper, L.Tapscott.

Thanks guys, plz rate ill rate your team if i havent already  ;)

Backs - Very strong. Not a fan of Otten but he is very tempting & should be a good cash cow so no problems there.

Mids - Good but I think Montagna is more of an upgrade target. Hallahan unlikely to get enough games.

Rucks - Lock & Load, No problems.

Fwds - Very good. No Petrie? Hooper & Tapscott are alright but I don't see them getting as many games as some others... but who knows with rookies yet ;)

Rioli and Prestia imo.

Overall very strong team 9/10 :)

[Junktimer]

hey maca,

backs: great line, no problems.

mids: still not a huge fan of joey, i think an MPP option or a cheaper premium such as boyd is better.  He wont be horrible, just is a tad in and out of games. -0.5

rucks: Wont penalise for it, but livethedream made a great comment how it is very tough to pick set and forget rucks.  I think if Petrie holds up pre season he is a better option than Jolly as your second ruck. could work though.

fwds: great line, no problems either.

overall, great team, 9.5/10

i have made a few edits too, reckon you could check mine?