Main Menu

Target 2011 Freo posts

Started by Cruiseon, December 14, 2010, 12:39:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Barlow 21

Barlow, Hill and Broughton/Duffield. :D

Junktimer


Barlow 21

Ooops yeah Mundy, Hill, Broughton, Barlow and Duffield. :D

valkorum

Quote from: Cruiseon on December 15, 2010, 10:09:25 AM

In order to keep this post kicking along I would like to ask a question, outside of Sandi & Pav, who are the best three current players at Freo? It drops off a lot after these guys and just wondering is there was any consensus?

I dont think it drops off much at all these days.

McPharlin
Barlow
Mundy

Followed closely by:

Hill
Duffman
Broughton
Balla

Junktimer

Quote from: valkorum on December 15, 2010, 11:23:16 AM
Quote from: Cruiseon on December 15, 2010, 10:09:25 AM

In order to keep this post kicking along I would like to ask a question, outside of Sandi & Pav, who are the best three current players at Freo? It drops off a lot after these guys and just wondering is there was any consensus?

I dont think it drops off much at all these days.

McPharlin
Barlow
Mundy

Followed closely by:

Hill
Duffman
Broughton
Balla

McPharlin ??? ???

Cruiseon

Quote from: valkorum on December 15, 2010, 11:23:16 AM
Quote from: Cruiseon on December 15, 2010, 10:09:25 AM

In order to keep this post kicking along I would like to ask a question, outside of Sandi & Pav, who are the best three current players at Freo? It drops off a lot after these guys and just wondering is there was any consensus?

I dont think it drops off much at all these days.

McPharlin
Barlow
Mundy

Followed closely by:

Hill
Duffman
Broughton
Balla

C'mon Valkorum, let's be a little bit objective here. You can't honestly tell me that it doesn't drop off. Sandi & Pav are class players, proven over time and there is light years between them and McPhalin and Barlow, the latter has played < 1 year of AFL!!!

I reckon (and hope)  Barlow could be great, and so could Hill but they are about 3 seasons away from being genuine week in week out a-grade players who cope with hard tags etc etc.


valkorum

Ok, I am being a bit speculative about Barlow being being in the same class as Pav/Sandi, but I stand by McPharlin and Mundy

When McPharlin is played only at CHB and not anywhere else as a "Mr Fix-it" then I would argue that he is one of the better CHB's going round. 

That is why I said followed closely by for Hill, Duffman, Broughton and Balla as they are not there yet but I see that they can be.

Barlow 21

AN EXCITING FUTURE
      A BOLD NEW LOOK
           FREMANTLE FC

Junktimer

I repeat: McPharlin ??? ???

not a bad player but no A grader

SydneyRox

Quote from: Junktimer on December 15, 2010, 02:12:35 PM
I repeat: McPharlin ??? ???

not a bad player but no A grader

Agree, dont rate him. However Mundy is a good choice

reesbr

Hill will get to the Pav and Sandi level soon

Barlow 21


Cruiseon


Barlow, c'mon stop using "+1" everywhere.

I appreciate you want to get your posts up but you've got help contribute, that's all part of the fun.

Junktimer

i agree, if there was a post minimum of 5 words, barlow would be in trouble

Barlow 21

Quote from: Cruiseon on December 15, 2010, 06:12:52 PM

Barlow, c'mon stop using "+1" everywhere.

I appreciate you want to get your posts up but you've got help contribute, that's all part of the fun.
+1 ;)
Yeah fair enough. Mundy really is the unsung hero of the Freo team.