FF Brownlow 2011

[MTTY]

So i was thinking that next year we could run a FF Brownlow where i put up a thread/poll for each game with every player that played and we vote for the best 3 players of the game. From this the top 3 from each game will get the votes, each poll will run for 24 hours and i will post the results of who is leading our Brownlow on this thread after each poll

[Barlow 21]

Okay, Sound Good. ;D

[ossie85]

I like that :)

I recommend opening the poll for a week though (otherwise people will miss the chance to vote :) ) and maybe click the option of not publishing the results until poll has expired?


Sounds great fun!


.... oh, and how would ties be decided?

[Justin Bieber]

Tie breaker vote?

Sounds like a good idea but will take alot of work to do for the whole season.

[MTTY]

I like that :)

I recommend opening the poll for a week though (otherwise people will miss the chance to vote :) ) and maybe click the option of not publishing the results until poll has expired?


Sounds great fun!

Yeah a week sounds much better. and for ties maybe we can refer to monty.


.... oh, and how would ties be decided?

[MTTY]

Tie breaker vote?

Sounds like a good idea but will take alot of work to do for the whole season.

I should be up to the work but if i am away or something like that i would be happy for someone to do it for that week or so

[pyronerd]

Tie breaker vote?

Sounds like a good idea but will take alot of work to do for the whole season.

I should be up to the work but if i am away or something like that i would be happy for someone to do it for that week or so

i would be happy to help if need be  ;)

[DazBurg]

love the idea MTTY

[hawk_88]

Would it be voting for best fantasy players or actually best and fairest?

[MTTY]

Would it be voting for best fantasy players or actually best and fairest?

Best on ground for example if a key defender was clealy the best on ground it wouldn't matter how many points he scored in fantasy

[pyronerd]

Would it be voting for best fantasy players or actually best and fairest?

Best on ground for example if a key defender was clealy the best on ground it wouldn't matter how many points he scored in fantasy

will be inetresting to see how the actual brownlow compares to the ff one

[Justin Bieber]

If it's based on fantasy points, no need really for us to vote then. It's really just a look up on their SC or DT scores ;).

[MajorLazer]

No it isn't based on fantasy, HP. Just BOG and two other players decided by FF.

[hawk_88]

Depends. You can also look at players in a fantasy context relative to themselves, for example a defender that averages 40 might have put in a fantasy blinder and scored 100 - a 250% performance.

That being said I'd prefer a normal vote based purely on footy performance. Just helps to clarify because some people's perception of a game is often warped by the fantasy scores they get at the end.

[ossie85]

Maybe tie breakers should be decided on SC/DT points or something?

I reckon I'll try and vote for 1 defender, 1 forward and 1 midfield per match.