Rate My Team Plz!

[Maca24]

Bomberboy well done :) like the rookies you have picked.
perfect rucks, great forwards (brennan nice unique IMO).
Mids look very good but higgens? im not sold on him. very injury prone.
Backs look great to. 8.87 out of ten. haha  :)
watson to heppell and higgens downgraded.

[mophead222]

Bomberboy well done :) like the rookies you have picked.
perfect rucks, great forwards (brennan nice unique IMO).
Mids look very good but higgens? im not sold on him. very injury prone.
Backs look great to. 8.87 out of ten. haha  :)
watson to heppell and higgens downgraded.

+1

[Maca24]

want me2 rate yours mop?  :)

[mophead222]

yes sir if thats ok

[Luigi197]

i rated an 8. i dont see much wrong with it, its just not a big powerhouse to me. probably needs to be a bit more solid, dont ask me how thats how i reckon it needs to be fixed.

Talia, Daw, Iles and Watson i reckon either wont play or if they do, wont be big scorers...
Otten, Higgins, Petrie, Brennan and Sidebottom are ones to watch the pre-season for.

and btw, when youve edited your team, remember to edit your original post and not repost plenty of times, just incase ;)

Luigi :)

[Junktimer]

Backs: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Brett Deledio, Lindsay Gilbee, Andy Otten, Matthew Watson, Sam Iles
BB:Tendai Mzungu, Paul Puopolo, Cameron Richardson
Mids: Dane Swan, Chris Judd, Leigh Montagna, Shaun Higgins, Reece Conca, David Swallow
MB: Shaun Atley, Andrew Krakeour, Dylan McNeil
Rucks: Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB: Zac Smith, Majak Daw
Forwards: Nick Riewoldt, Cyril Rioli, Matthew Pavlich, Drew Petrie, Jared Brennan, Steele Sidebottom, Jack Darling
FB: Daniel Talia, Thomas Lynch, Luke Tapscott
Rate out of 10 and explain why.

Gday BB

backs: Gilbee is inconsistent, i had him this year and he killed me a few times, id go for maybe kelly or someone like that. i reckon a few of the rookies could change, not sure about watson or iles.  maybe jacobs and toy instead. -0.5

mids: dont like higgins at all, the man is made of butter.  the rest is fine. -0.5

rucks: all fine.

fwds: Jared Brennan?  at a very awkward price, and hes quite inconsistent.  Daniel Talia IMO should not be chosen as you have no one to switch MPP with him.  Also Tom Lynch is a bad choice as he is very expensive and is a KPP, big boys take time.  -1

Overall good team, 8/10

can you rate mine?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html

[bomberboy0618]

team edited :)

[Barlow 21]

Great Team
Only negatives are 3 rookie backs. -2
Steele Sidebottom in forwards. -0.5
Otherwise very good. :D
7.5/10

[bomberboy0618]

Great Team
Only negatives are 3 rookie backs. -2
Steele Sidebottom in forwards. -0.5
Otherwise very good. :D
7.5/10

thanks :D
i might change rookies  :-\

[Barlow 21]

Great Team
Only negatives are 3 rookie backs. -2
Steele Sidebottom in forwards. -0.5
Otherwise very good. :D
7.5/10

thanks :D
i might change rookies  :-\

Okay Good Idea BB

[mophead222]

Great Team
Only negatives are 3 rookie backs. -2
Steele Sidebottom in forwards. -0.5
Otherwise very good. :D
7.5/10

whats wrong with sidey ??

[pyronerd]

Great Team
Only negatives are 3 rookie backs. -2
Steele Sidebottom in forwards. -0.5
Otherwise very good. :D
7.5/10

whats wrong with sidey ??

yeah what is wrong with him  ???

[MajorLazer]

Sidebottom will be a star.

[pyronerd]

Sidebottom will be a star.

+11111111 despite him playing for collingwood i am a fan  :P

[MajorLazer]

Sidebottom will be a star.

+11111111 despite him playing for collingwood i am a fan  :P

I know you are Pyro and I think you know I am. ;)
Playing for Collingwood is the only negative. :P