Rate My Team Plz!

[bomberboy0618]

Backs: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Brett Deledio, James Kelly, Andy Otten, Ben Jacobs, Josh Toy
BB:Tendai Mzungu, Paul Puopolo, Cameron Richardson
Mids: Dane Swan, Chris Judd, Leigh Montagna, Andrew Gaff, Reece Conca, David Swallow
MB: Shaun Atley, Andrew Krakeour, Dylan McNeil
Rucks: Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB: Zac Smith, Majak Daw
Forwards: Nick Riewoldt, Cyril Rioli, Matthew Pavlich, Drew Petrie, Brad Green, Steele Sidebottom, Jack Darling
FB: Tom McDonald, Dion Prestia, Luke Tapscott
Rate out of 10 and explain why.
53000 left.

[erich1036]

Solid backline there. Maybe swap watson and richardson around.

All clear in the midfield and ruck.

Not sure if brennan deserves a spot in the team, he can be a bit inconsistent and not sure if darling should start in the 22.

Apart from that its pretty solid, i would rate 9 :)

I would appreciate it if you could rate mine too ;)

[bomberboy0618]

Thanks :D
The rookies will change, and brennan I like as a smokie.
Will rate now :)

[roo boys!]

Solid backline there. Maybe swap watson and richardson around.

All clear in the midfield and ruck.

Not sure if brennan deserves a spot in the team, he can be a bit inconsistent and not sure if darling should start in the 22.

Apart from that its pretty solid, i would rate 9 :)

I would appreciate it if you could rate mine too ;)

Welcome to the forum erich :)

[erich1036]

Thanks roo boys! Hopefully I can give a lot to this footy loving community! :)

[bomberboy0618]

Thanks roo boys! Hopefully I can give a lot to this footy loving community! :)

Welcome to the forum mate, hopefully you are to stay :)

[erich1036]

Yeah, I'm here to stay haha. Supercoach is my main priority at the moment though haha :)

[McRooster]

1. How much coin do you have left?
2. 4 Magpies? (who have 2 byes in regular season-where you won't have them scoring in the all important league match)
3. One less upper echelon mid and spend the coin elsewhere (upgrade to Montagna later- this then leaves you with 2 Saints, a much more absorbable #)
4. Brennan is brave and I won't go there, although reward coulde be had with GC lacking forward firepower. However I can't see Tapscott, Talia or Lynch and possibly Darling playing round one to cover for Brennan when GC has the first up bye.
5. Higgins with his body history, I'd go Foley or Harris.

7.5/10, Few tweaks here and there and she'll be a 9  ;)

Good work.

[bomberboy0618]

Thanks, I'll change after :)
I have bout 70k left.

[ossie85]

Gilbee, Higgins and Brennan I'm not huge fans of. Think there output potential isn't as good as it should be, and possible better options elsewhere (Kelly, Foley and can't think of a forward atm lol are better options :) ).

I like Sidebottom as a pick, and could slip into my side. Entering his third year and on the back of a very impressive grand final could be one to step up a gear. On the other hand, will probably get more attention.

Great team though, and think would be a solid league team and would come home strong :)

[bomberboy0618]

who voted 1 :(

[MTTY]

1. Even though i think Talia could slip into Adelaide's team for RND 1 i think he will take 1 more year to really score well if he debuts this year.

2. Lynch i would think won't debut in RND 1 i reckon he will be put into the GC reserve team to develop.

3.Watson even though he has the physique might take time to develop and probably won't score high as a KPP.

4. As others have said Montagna probably an upgrade target.

5. I like Higgins and if he plays well in NAB then i will consider him myself especially if he remains fit.

6. I see Brennan scoring well next year at GC, so i think for the ones who take the risk on him they will be rewarded

Overall 7.5/10

[Barlow 21]

Thanks :D
The rookies will change, and brennan I like as a smokie.
Will rate now :)

+1 Brennan is a nice smokie. So too Ziebell. ;)

[MajorLazer]

Doesn't matter who voted 1, BB. In polls there is always someone who votes the lowest and hopes they stay anonymous.

Btw I voted 8. :)

[roo boys!]

Thanks :D
The rookies will change, and brennan I like as a smokie.
Will rate now :)

+1 Brennan is a nice smokie. So too Ziebell. ;)

I agree, they are both in my team ;)