Please rate mine and i will rate yours - DT

[j959]

Bahahahahahaha Junktimer...

Roo is the number 2 forward in the comp behind chappy if not equal in value.

If you dont know the numbers dont give your worthless advice

are you serious Alphaman??

[Alphaman]

you 2 peanuts arent serious are you?

Roo is the best value forward in DT by a country mile!

Yeah you pay 400k for pav he will average you 95 awesome, you pay for what u get..

Roo is in a complete class of his own and fully fit should average 105-110.

Junktimer you may talk a lot on fan footy but that last comment about taking pav over roo makes me think you have not much of an idea about DT.

[j959]

you 2 peanuts arent serious are you?

Roo is the best value forward in DT by a country mile!

Yeah you pay 400k for pav he will average you 95 awesome, you pay for what u get..

Roo is in a complete class of his own and fully fit should average 105-110.

Junktimer you may talk a lot on fan footy but that last comment about taking pav over roo makes me think you have not much of an idea about DT.

i meant your comment about "worthless advice" - seems you may need to go back to posting etiqutte class mate

[Junktimer]

it may not have been the best advice to give.  i retract the statement.  i was trying to find a point of feedback cause i didnt have much to say about it.

[j959]

you 2 peanuts arent serious are you?

Roo is the best value forward in DT by a country mile!

Yeah you pay 400k for pav he will average you 95 awesome, you pay for what u get..

Roo is in a complete class of his own and fully fit should average 105-110.

Junktimer you may talk a lot on fan footy but that last comment about taking pav over roo makes me think you have not much of an idea about DT.

i meant your comment about "worthless advice" - seems you may need to go back to posting etiqutte class mate

have a look at how people like ossie, hellopplz, Master Q and McRooster post ratings replies - they give constructive feedback.

you've got some decent comments, but ones like,

"crap side ..." &
"worst team ive seen posted by far"

don't help anyone

[Alphaman]

pav = 400k will average you 95
Roo = 400k will average you 105-110 (cheap for what he does)

Saying if you pick pav over roo ill slap you, and saying it was worthless advice mean exactly the same thing.

One is just sugar coated and the other is straight to the point.

[hally25547]

i would always go roo over pav. now lets get back to criticising and improving my side ;)

[Alphaman]

i think your team is good. I dont think you really need any more advice or changing. only thing to do is watch pre season and pick the best rookies and it will be fine

[zeddyzed]

Come round 6 you will have Hodge, Kelly, Broughton, Mzunga, Sandilands and Franklin with byes =/

[elephants]

Backs - very common but solid. not quite sold on otten yet but apparently he is doing well at training

Mids - haha almost exactly the same as mine so i am unable to critisize other than maybe having boyd AND swan making your mids to expensive, other cheaper premiums include cross and the likes :)

Rucks - Sandi is a lock, i (along with thousands of other dters) assume petrie will be back to form from a couple of years back :)

Forwards - premiums are all good, i would have sylvia but he was not good to me last year so he is a nono for me :) prestia is a gun apparently so 'watch this space' and i think you may as well utilise petrie's r/f ability :)

thanks mate i rated it 8/10

[brownyyy]

good team, probs an 8.5 outta 10. only concern would be grimes and brown with injurys. otherwise good!

[Hawka]

hodgey out gibbs in ;)

[Cicjose]

i think that is the general consensus going around

[PowerMan]

After having a few attempts already this is my current team - what do you guys think? My main concerns with it are the backline strength and whether to have tapscott or harper as my last fwd bench. Feel free to add any suggestion, criticism or just your opinion. And if you post the link i will comment on yours as well. Cheers,

Backs: Goddard (C), Hodge (C), Kelly (C), Broughton, Grimes, Otten, Jacobs - Mzungu, Richardson, Toy

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Anthony, Swallow, Gaff, Heppell (B) - Wallis, Krakour, Hallahan

Rucks: Sandlilands, Petrie (F) - Smith, Lycett

Forwards - Franklin, Sylvia (C), Thomas, N Reiwoldt, Brown, Knights, Prestia - Smith, Matera, Tapscott

cheers :)

very good team.  9/10

I would change Jack Grimes for maybe Jed Adcock.  Grimes is injury prone.

and Adcock isn't. LMAO!

[Junktimer]

After having a few attempts already this is my current team - what do you guys think? My main concerns with it are the backline strength and whether to have tapscott or harper as my last fwd bench. Feel free to add any suggestion, criticism or just your opinion. And if you post the link i will comment on yours as well. Cheers,

Backs: Goddard (C), Hodge (C), Kelly (C), Broughton, Grimes, Otten, Jacobs - Mzungu, Richardson, Toy

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Anthony, Swallow, Gaff, Heppell (B) - Wallis, Krakour, Hallahan

Rucks: Sandlilands, Petrie (F) - Smith, Lycett

Forwards - Franklin, Sylvia (C), Thomas, N Reiwoldt, Brown, Knights, Prestia - Smith, Matera, Tapscott

cheers :)

very good team.  9/10

I would change Jack Grimes for maybe Jed Adcock.  Grimes is injury prone.

and Adcock isn't. LMAO!

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,19020.0.html

just dont talk.