First time team

[westcats]

First time team
hi all this is  my first team on fan planner would love to have it rated and any advice would be great

Backs
Goddard (c/b) Hodge (c/b) Broughton , Waite f/b ,Hurn, Ottens , Davis (Mzungu,Richardson,Toy)
Mids
Swan, Boyd,Jack,Foley,D.swallow,Gaff (Heppell b/c, Weller,McNeil c/f
Rucks
Sandilands,Petrie R/f (Smith,Cordy)
Fwds
Chapman c/f,N.riewoldt,Green c/f ,Pavlich c/f ,Goodes c/f ,Darling,Lamb (hooper,Matera,Taliab/f

$33,700 left
rookies will change by season start e,g mpp and nab cup form

[ossie85]

Honestly don't have much too add!

9/10. Awesome first attempt

[Lippa]

Not bad. May get caught with mid bench.

I would downgrade green or goodes to upgrade Lamb. Playing 2 rookie forwards could be risky.

8/10

[SydneyRox]

Yeah looks ok for your first run 7.5/10. Darling and Lamb as starters in your Fwd line is a bit risky, as they might struggle for the game time. Prestia and Isacc Smith might be better options?

[j959]

8.5/10
i'll do the ever popular Waite bashing (inconsistent/tribunal risk) and offer Grimes (barring inj concerns) as a Melb option that shouldn't be affected by the bye situation.

SydneyRox, think he can't have Prestia cos he's already got Matera on his fwd bench - i really wanted Prestia but then GC selected him and Matera is cheaper.

i'm not personally sold on Foley but i see that it fits your mid structure well.
agree with Lippa's comment about the risk of 2 rookie fwds but being a Swans supporter I reckon you should keep Lamb and upgrade Darling.  ;)