New Team (RATE!)

[bomberboy0618]

This is my team...
Backs: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Brett Deledio, James Kelly, Harry O’Brien, Matthew Watson, Sam Iles
BB:Tendai Mzungu, Paul Puopolo, Cameron Richardson
Mids: Dane Swan, Chris Judd,  Leigh Montagna, Alan Didak, Reece Conca, David Swallow
MB: Shaun Atley, Andrew Krakeour, Dylan McNeil
Rucks: Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB: Zac Smith, Majak Daw
Forwards: Nick Riewoldt, Cyril Rioli, Matthew Pavlich, Drew Petrie, Jared Brennan, Jack Darling, Jed Lamb
FB: Daniel Talia, Thomas Lynch, Luke Tapscott
I have 78,400 left.
Rate and comment :D !

[j959]

8.5

you sure you didn't go over budget BB??
looks very solid across all lines.

my one worry would be the the usual Brennan bashing - inconsistency/tribunal.

other than that, very strong

[BoredSaint]

9
looks like a pretty solid team

[bomberboy0618]

nah just under budget :D
yeah brennan may change just i have a feeling about him.
A new club may do him well.
Anyway i tried a few smokies.
Thanks for the feedback :D do u have a team that i could rate?

[MajorLazer]

I'm also not sure about Brennan but could be a smokie so not a definite downside.

I reckon you need Swallow though.

8.67/10

[bomberboy0618]

I'm also not sure about Brennan but could be a smokie so not a definite downside.

I reckon you need Swallow though.

8.67/10

Fixed :D
i had him just when i was fiddling forgot him.
Better than my other team?

[j959]

nah just under budget :D
yeah brennan may change just i have a feeling about him.
A new club may do him well.

fair enuff

Anyway i tried a few smokies.
Thanks for the feedback :D do u have a team that i could rate?

not yet BB, thought i'd put one up after pre-season draft next week.
probably prefer to put team up after NAB Cup but think it gets a bit busy at that time and you'd lose the quality comments for quantity?

[bomberboy0618]

nah just under budget :D
yeah brennan may change just i have a feeling about him.
A new club may do him well.

fair enuff

Anyway i tried a few smokies.
Thanks for the feedback :D do u have a team that i could rate?

not yet BB, thought i'd put one up after pre-season draft next week.
probably prefer to put team up after NAB Cup but think it gets a bit busy at that time and you'd lose the quality comments for quantity?

yeah i agree, not so much u lose the quality, there is definately more people who just randomly post, though other people would be more qualified to tell you ;)

[tom_scully]

Yay! someone finally who put the best defenders in defence GOD and Hodge

[bomberboy0618]

Yay! someone finally who put the best defenders in defence GOD and Hodge

can u rate it plz :D

[tom_scully]

Yay! someone finally who put the best defenders in defence GOD and Hodge

can u rate it plz :D

No poll to rate it, but:
Kelly, is a slow starter and a better upgrade option (check his stats on this site - AWESOME WORK MONTY!!!!!!!!!!)
6 rookies, too many for my liking (assuming watson is a rookie)
I have said enough already about atley and mcneil on this site.

[jimmytigs]

This is my team...
Backs: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Brett Deledio, James Kelly, Harry O’Brien, Matthew Watson, Sam Iles
BB:Tendai Mzungu, Paul Puopolo, Cameron Richardson
Mids: Dane Swan, Chris Judd,  Leigh Montagna, Alan Didak, Reece Conca, David Swallow
MB: Shaun Atley, Andrew Krakeour, Dylan McNeil
Rucks: Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB: Zac Smith, Majak Daw
Forwards: Nick Riewoldt, Cyril Rioli, Matthew Pavlich, Drew Petrie, Jared Brennan, Jack Darling, Jed Lamb
FB: Daniel Talia, Thomas Lynch, Luke Tapscott
I have 78,400 left.
Rate and comment :D !

Question marks over mcneil & daw,just for mpp i cant justify picking 2 guys if they are no chance of playing.But overall your backs mids & rucks are good(kelly gets injured & did collingwood work out montagna?id go boyd instead).Dont like forward line though,last 5 are far from guarenteed a game & aside from pav the other 4 are either injury prone(roo & petrie),hot & cold(rioli) or injury/suspension prone(brennan).Im a saints fan but id have buddy,in fact he & judd are my 2 sc absolute musts along with swan & sandi & goddard i guess,but buddy & judd score well even when beaten on the day,keep petrie for mpp but along with roo get rid of brennan & rioli.

[mophead222]

This is my team...
Backs: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Brett Deledio, James Kelly, Harry O’Brien, Matthew Watson, Sam Iles
BB:Tendai Mzungu, Paul Puopolo, Cameron Richardson
Mids: Dane Swan, Chris Judd,  Leigh Montagna, Alan Didak, Reece Conca, David Swallow
MB: Shaun Atley, Andrew Krakeour, Dylan McNeil
Rucks: Aaron Sandilands, Darren Jolly
RB: Zac Smith, Majak Daw
Forwards: Nick Riewoldt, Cyril Rioli, Matthew Pavlich, Drew Petrie, Jared Brennan, Jack Darling, Jed Lamb
FB: Daniel Talia, Thomas Lynch, Luke Tapscott
I have 78,400 left.
Rate and comment :D !

not huge on Harry O'B, .

Like your mids, but would rather see didak out coz you have 3 pies. maybe downgrade to gaff then upgrade Harry to Broughton.

Great rucks, also maybe swap Daw for Mcdonald of melbourne, daw ran the slowest time trial in the North pre season, then they did it a second time and gave him a head start but the same result occurred, so i think daw is a while off pushing for senior selection.

Solid fowards, just not huge on lamb starting, not sure how many games he will get early on in the season.

overall 7.8/10 :)

rate my team?

[Barlow 21]

Good but be wary of Harry O. McNeil should break into the swans senior side. ;)

[bomberboy0618]

Good but be wary of Harry O. McNeil should break into the swans senior side. ;)

Harry o is a smokie.
Rate out of ten barlow