The team to beat?

Started by MTTY, November 26, 2010, 09:05:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Rate

Bad
2 (15.4%)
Ok
1 (7.7%)
Pretty Good
2 (15.4%)
Impressive
7 (53.8%)
Awesome
1 (7.7%)

Total Members Voted: 0

MTTY

B- Hodge, Deledio, Goddard, Broughton, Bock, Otten, Mzungu- BENCH- Richardson, Harvey, Coad

M- Boyd,  A.Swallow, Swan, D. Swallow, Gaff, Heppell- BENCH- J.Simpkin, Callinan, Krakouer

R- Sandilands, Petrie- BENCH- Smith, Lycett

F- N.Riewoldt, Rioli, Pavlich, Chapman, Sylvia, Knights, Darling- BENCH - McDonald, Lamb, Karnezis


Criticism welcomed :)

Barlow 21

Cooney, Chapman, Day ???

Otherwise very good.

MTTY

Quote from: Barlow 21 on November 26, 2010, 09:14:32 PM
Cooney, Chapman, Day ???

Otherwise very good.
why whats wrong with them?

Maca24

think they are all fine MTTY. great team 9/10.
dont rate sylvia at all but thats just me.
apart from that team is solid. you gota have pendles or swan though.

MTTY

Quote from: Maca24 on November 26, 2010, 09:36:57 PM
think they are all fine MTTY. great team 9/10.
dont rate sylvia at all but thats just me.
apart from that team is solid. you gota have pendles or swan though.
Cheers Maca the Cooney spot is likely to change i just prefer him for now but will probably turn into someone else

Barlow 21

Chapman - Injury Prone, Will be tagged in GAJ`s absence - Getting Old
Day - KPP - Unlikely to score well a la J.Watts.
Cooney - Will be tagged - Overpriced

7.5/10

benjy251090

Cooney is not the best choice, very inconsistent

Don't see the point in McDonald or Talia as you don't have MPP for the other positions they can play and there are possibly better options

Be wary of an Ablett-less Chapman, could either shine or spud it up, your choice


Boomz

I'd say he is assuming Day is MPP...

Agree with the others about Chapman I'm staying away for those reasons. Cooney is alright but better options.
8/10

MTTY


Barlow 21


MTTY

Just added a chart to my team thoughts?

MTTY

Any more opinions/criticism

Junktimer

really good team.

cant find many faults.

i have a few queries however, day is a KPP and even if he does play i cant see him scoring too much, i would trade him for his teammate prestia who is a ready made player.

the absence of swan will hurt.

apart from that, very good.

9/10

MTTY

Quote from: Junktimer on December 01, 2010, 11:25:43 PM
really good team.

cant find many faults.

i have a few queries however, day is a KPP and even if he does play i cant see him scoring too much, i would trade him for his teammate prestia who is a ready made player.

the absence of swan will hurt.

apart from that, very good.

9/10
Cheers.

Yeah i will wait to NAB to make my final decision for Days spot it will probably be one of- Isaac Smith, Prestia, Harper, Day, Howe, Tappy or Matera

jimmytigs

Quote from: MTTY on November 26, 2010, 09:05:00 PM
B- Hodge, Deledio, Kelly, Broughton, Drummond(Hurn or Bock), Otten, Mzungu- BENCH- Richardson, Jacobs, Coad

Three gun consistent MPP's. Broughton is going to keep improving and become a 100 consistent scorer. Drummond, Hurn or Bock  is the cheap premium scorer. Otten an underpriced gem for SC. Mzungu racks up a lot of the pill. Bench three rookies who should make me a lot of cash and all should start RND 1 bar Coad.

M- Boyd,  Goddard, Chapman, D. Swallow, Gaff, Heppell- BENCH- Parker, Weller, Krakouer

Went with the Best available C/B and F/C. Then a consistent 100 scorer in Boyd. Swallow, Gaff and Heppell are high 1st RND picks that should all start in there teams opening games. Bench players all should start for their teams and get a load of games to make them great cash cows.

R- Sandilands, Petrie- BENCH- Smith, McDonald

Sandilands is the best ruckman in the comp. Petrie is way underpriced for what he can do. Smith will make a ton of cash and should play nearly all games. MCdonald is there for MPP, and i think he may get game time at Melbourne as a pinch hitter ruck mainly playing forward or defence.

F- N.Riewoldt, Rioli, Pavlich, Thomas, Sylvia, Knights, Day- BENCH - Darling, Lamb, Karnezis

Two champion forwards in Riewoldt and Pav. Rioli, Thomas and Sylvia should get a lot of time in the midfield which wwill boost their scoring capacity as a forward. Knights is an underpriced gun that should get a lot more time in the midfield. Day is a huge talent that will score well IMO and if MPP will be even better. Darling and Lamb should both get a lot of games and are underpriced for what they can do. Karnezis maybe won't play RND 1 but should get a lot of games if his NAB form is good, i see him as the replacement for Brennan.

The following chart shows what player will be out at certain RNDs and who i could replace them barring that i will make trades for upgrades/downgrades and injuries along the way.

Key- FP- Field Premium
        FFP- Field Fallen Premium
        FM- Field Almost Premium
        FC- Field Cheap
        FR- Field Rookie
        BR- Bench Rookie


RND 1- 2FR, 3BR- Darling/Lamb/Karnezis, Parker/Krakouer

RND 2- 2FC- Darling/Lamb/Karnezis, Richardson/Coad/Jacobs

RND 3- 1FC, 1BR- Smith/McDonald

RND 4- BYE- 1FFP, 2FP, 1FR, 2BR- Ricardson/Jacobs/Coad, Parker/Krakouer, Lamb, Weller/Krakouer

RND 5- 1FP, 1FM, 3BR- Weller/Krakouer, Darling/Karnezis

RND 6- BYE- (MPP) 7FP, 1BR- Coad/Jacobs, Richardson/Jacobs, Parker/Krakouer, Weller/Krakouer, Darling/Karnezis, Lamb/Karnezis

RND 7- 1FM, 1BR- Darling/Lamb/Karnezis

RND 8- NONE

RND 9- SAME as RND 1

RND 10- 1FR- Parker/Weller/Krakouer

RND 11- FP- Richardson/Coad/Mzungu

RND 12- 1BR

RND 13- 1FM, 1BR- Lamb/Darling/Karnezis

RND 14- 2FP- Parker/Weller/Krakouer, Lamb/Darling/Karnezis

RND 15- 1FP- Parker/Weller/Krakouer

RND 16- BYE- 2FM, 2FP, 2FC, 1FR, 1BR- Ricardson/Jacobs, Coad/Jacobs, Smith, Lamb/Weller/Krakouer/Parker, Darling/Weller/Krakouer/Parker, Karnezis/Weller/Krakouer/Parker

RND 17- 2FP- Richardson/Coad/Jacobs, Lamb/Darling/Karnezis

RND 18- 1BR

RND 19- BYE- 1FP, 1FFP, 3BR- Richardon/Jacobs, Coad/Jacobs

RND 20- 1FR, 1BR- Parker/Weller/Krakouer

RND 21- 1FC, 1BR- Smith/McDonald

RND 22- 2FP- Richardson/Coad/Jacobs, Parker/Weller/Krakouer

RND 23- NONE

RND 24- 1FR- Parker/Weller/Krakouer





Criticism welcomed :)

hurn or bock not drummond & backline is a winner,swan in for chapman i dont care how & mids are a winner,mcdonald into forward line for day so you can make use of mpp & bailey into ruck & rucks are ok,riewoldt rioli & lamb all out for buddy & 2 others perhaps hooper of dogs & even fev or someone more expensive without knowing your cash situation,forget about mpp for f/c unless there are better options,youd be sacrificing a premium mid like swan or good cash cow rookies its not worth it.