New teams Pre Draft

Started by pie time, November 18, 2010, 11:32:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

pie time


Updated teams
Fisher,hurn,duffield,grimes,houli,otten,richardson emg:Iles,watson,K.hunt
Swan,Goddard,Judd,Gaff,Hodge,D>Swallow emg Heppell,Atley,Krakouer
Petrie,Jolly EMG: DAY , Bailey
Chapman, Roo,Gray,Thomas,LeCras,Darling,Pettard EMG:Hooper,Matera,Butcher

Team 2
Goddard,Hodge,Duffield,Grimes,houli,Otten,Davis EMG K.Hunt,Illes,Richardson

Judd,Montagna,Pendles,Hannebery,Atley,D.Swallow EMG Stanley,Conca,Krakouer

Jolly,McIntosh EMG: Day and Daw

Chappy,Roo,Pettard,Stevie J,Darling,Hooper,Sylvia EMG Lamb,Matera & Cook

Please comment on which is best side now and comment on changes


nas

Reckon Day is way too much to be sitting on the bench as a ruck reserve could be a fwd/ruck so would be better as a fwd. know that the planner has him currently as ruck but reckon that could change >> imo

benjy251090

I agree naste, I don't think I will make another team until Feb when we find out all the MPP's

nas

Yep i have my team done just a few tweaks here n there and awaiting mpp status like Day maybe etc etc  so all heresay at this point of time.

benjy251090


pie time

I agree with Day, was surprised to see him as a ruckman

j959

whoa! Monty's already updated fanplanner - the man is a machine!

what do you guys think with Gorringe at GC - I'm worried by all there being so many potential rucks competing for spots, eg Z Smith, Fraser, Day (if he does play as a ruck ...

Justin Bieber

I would say Smith and Gorringe will play rucks. Day and Fraser used up forward. They need experience up forward and Fraser is more of a natural forward than ruckman.

Although if somebody was to not make the team from those three, Gorringe more than likely will be the one as Smith was great in the VFL this year.

j959

Quote from: Hellopplz on November 19, 2010, 12:25:45 PM
I would say Smith and Gorringe will play rucks. Day and Fraser used up forward. They need experience up forward and Fraser is more of a natural forward than ruckman.

Although if somebody was to not make the team from those three, Gorringe more than likely will be the one as Smith was great in the VFL this year.
yeah, makes the ruck bench choices less difficult - no point having Zmith and Gorringe in there at the same time.