Main Menu

Who got the best of the draft 2010

Started by MTTY, November 18, 2010, 10:24:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

MTTY

Apart from GC who got the best out of the draft post in your order
1.Carlton
2.NM.
3.WCE
4.Brisbane
5.Cats
6.Port
7.WB
8.Sydney
9.Freo
10.Hawks
11.Melbourne
12.Essendon
13.Richmond
14.STK
15.Collingwood
16.Adelaide

Andrew3737

Richmond should be 15th or 16th. They did terrible again.

CrowsFan

Not surprised you put adelaide last considering they only got 2 new players.
But I have heard good things about both of them :)

MTTY

Quote from: CrowsFan on November 18, 2010, 11:08:58 PM
Not surprised you put adelaide last considering they only got 2 new players.
But I have heard good things about both of them :)
Yeah that was the main reason for me though Brodie Smith is an excellent player

Justin Bieber

Carlton, West Coast, Lions, Cats, Kangas, Sydney and the Bulldogs (in no particular order).
Geelong did well to replace their ageing backman.
Kangas only get the mention due to the Atley pick so low.
Sydney did well getting a Forward, Midfielder and 2 defenders. First two picks were very solid.

Richmond didn't do entirely bad. Conca isn't that bad (although shouldn't of been taken that high) and Batch is a pretty solid Half Back.

Andrew3737


MTTY

Quote from: Hellopplz on November 18, 2010, 11:15:28 PM
Carlton, West Coast, Lions, Cats, Kangas, Sydney and the Bulldogs (in no particular order).
Geelong did well to replace their ageing backman.
Kangas only get the mention due to the Atley pick so low.
Sydney did well getting a Forward, Midfielder and 2 defenders. First two picks were very solid.

Richmond didn't do entirely bad. Conca isn't that bad (although shouldn't of been taken that high) and Batch is a pretty solid Half Back.
The Kanagas did extremly well
Atley, Harper, Delaney and Mabon

Justin Bieber

I really know Atley and Harper out of the Kangas' picks. But I'm no expert in rookies :P.

hawk_88

I'm not an expert on the kids either, but from the little I know I think the Hawks did very well.

Would have thought Smith, Hallahan and Litherland all would have gone earlier. You could tell the Hawks were surprised too as they took considerable time to make up their mind. From what I am hearing Puopolo (our 4th round pick) might slot straight into the 22.

2 mature age and 2 young ones. Few defenders and most importantly some pace (something I think we severely lack).

Add in the fact that Bruce will most likely be joining us in the Pre-Season Draft and I think the Hawks did very well considering their position in the order.

ossie85

Time will tell! Impossible to tell now :)

8-6 Suited

I think everyone is writing off Collingwoods picks, as it strengthens the Pies forwardine to match its extremely solid backline and midfielders.

Fasolo will replace Davis in the side, and thats a bad thing for the opponents as he can kick straight. :P

BratPack


Justin Bieber

You got a new Canadian to follow ;). And he plays for the Bombers!!!!