HTM - Super Team 2011.. Rate

[benjy251090]

Last year I didn't know what I was doing really :P

Summary of your team:
Backs:
Hodge, Lids and Fish: Good solid players, nothing wrong there
Bradley: Did well in the games he played but he missed the last several games of the season so I am unsure whether he will get games.
Hurley: I agree with you and he may make my team but at this stage unsure for mine, but nothing wrong IMO for you.
Henderson and Myers: Spuds, change them both for rookies or one for a rookie and one for a premium.
Rookies: At this stage you can't judge rookies but look at the likes of Jacobs, Mzungu, Iles, Toy and Coad, bug wraps on all of them.

Mids:
God and Pav: Nothing wrong with these two.
Sidebottom: Could be good but could just as easily be bad with Krakouer and the likes entering the team, but still an OK pick.
Higgins and Hartlett: Both way too injury prone, they have potential but miss out on too much of the season to warrant a pick. Get rid of one for a rookie and upgrade the other.
Rookies: Like Swallow and Harper but ON and McNeil are iffy, ON is a spud and McNeil is not needed seeing you already have a C/F in your mids, look out for other rookies others mentioned.

Rucks:
Hille: I like Hille too but seeing Essendon are missing round 24, you will need to trade him out to beat me ;)
Trengove: Was good last year as cover but was pretty useless and is not worth it at his price, would rather you start Smith and put Bailey on your bench rather than Trengove.
Rookies: Nothing wrong there.

Fwds:
Chappy, Roo and Didak: Solid picks, nothing wrong.
Waite: I like him but finds himself suspended too much, but still nothing wrong with picking him.
Jurrah: Exciting player and I think he will have a good year, but I don't think he is ready for Super Coach yet.
Wright: Spud, get rid of him for a rookie.
Petrie: Nuffie pick, everyone will have him so nothing wrong there.
Rookies: You don't need Talia and Retzlaff with you already having Waite as a B/F as they are not certain to play, however if they do play they are good to get, Shepheard is fine as well. Look for the likes of Butcher, Lamb and Darling as well.

I am giving it 6/10, just too many mid-pricers that could be flops and not enough quality rookies. Well that is just my opinion and you did beat me this year so what would I know :P

[Master Q]

B :Penjy, don't try and change the subject to save your friend, let us have some time to laugh at his team and post suggestions. HTM, here are the results so far from the Poll:

$1.80 to any League    0 (0%)
8/10   0 (0%)
Average    2 (22.2%)
Poor Team No Offence   2 (22.2%)
What are you thinking? Spud Team   5 (55.6%)
 
Total Members Voted: 9

Justice has been served.

And now for my view:

Shocking. And if you were to rate your own team the way you rate others, you'd give it 0.5/10 .

[benjy251090]

Haha, Q, I wasn't changing subject, I was telling him why he has such a bad team :P

[Justin Bieber]

I gave it a poor team. For me, too much use of MPP.

Don't mind Lachie or Hurley down back as they could both improve being young but maybe 1 in backs and 1 up forward opening another space for a premium instead of Waite (or change one of them).

Bradley is........
Myers certainly has some talent and could be a great pick up but can his body actually withstand from getting injured? Could be solid like Gumby was this year.

Centres I think you stocked up too much on MPP forwards. Honestly, I would probably only have 1 to start the year. Most of the scoring comes from pure midfielders, so could be better to have them with 1 MPP forward and 1 Back.

Rucks, Don't rate Trengove as a fantasy player even if he has MPP status (Good solid player though). I don't believe you need MPP with the Rucks as it has only 2 positions (easy to cover or trade if you start with premiums).

Forwards I think look the best for me. Don't have a problem with them except for Petrie and Wright being from the same team. Could test your bench.

Bench is alright but I doubt you'll end up going in with the majority of them (like the others said).

[Boomz]

If this really isn't a joke team... Then you have worried way too much about MPP because half the MPP players u have won't even get games so u will have no cover anyway...

[Justin Bieber]

Steele Sidebottom in the starting midfield? Are you kidding me? lol No Swan or Pendlebury? That's a problem.

I might not have any of them at the start :P.

[HTM]

Shocking. And if you were to rate your own team the way you rate others, you'd give it 0.5/10 .

0.5 are you serious?... i would give any team 0.5 just for trying

[Holz]

now this is a poor team, maybee you should have a look at my team.
most of the backline i would not pick, only 1 rookie in the middle, trengove (are you serious) and wright has to be the worst pick of the bunch, he scores poorly and i think he might not even get games next year.

serious question, im not sure if there is a random team option like there is when dt starts but if it exists is that how you made this team, or is this actually your team.

[Master Q]

Shocking. And if you were to rate your own team the way you rate others, you'd give it 0.5/10 .

0.5 are you serious?... i would give any team 0.5 just for trying

Look at your posts! Stingey and Picky as Hell!

now this is a poor team, maybee you should have a look at my team.
most of the backline i would not pick, only 1 rookie in the middle, trengove (are you serious) and wright has to be the worst pick of the bunch, he scores poorly and i think he might not even get games next year.

serious question, im not sure if there is a random team option like there is when dt starts but if it exists is that how you made this team, or is this actually your team.

Totally Agree, I think this thread doens't deserve to has "Super Team" in it.

Maybe "HTM's Home of Duds" ?

[Maca24]

lol and tool of the week goes to HTM for dishing it out and producing the worst team seen on the forum lol

[Master Q]

lol and tool of the week goes to HTM for dishing it out and producing the worst team seen on the forum lol

Tool of the Weeks over  :( but he could win Tool of the Summer?

[Boomz]

I think he has already sown up tool of the week for next year.

[nas]

could be a Sidcrome?

[HTM]

Some people found me out... i thought i shall tell everyone now.. this is definitely not the team i will have... in other words, fake team..

However i did put a few players up that i thought i would consider, as smokies.. eg Jurrah or Harlett

Some of this help was beneficial... and some people listed on how could improve this team, which still in a way help.. i went for a multiple postions line up aswell, only having about 8 out of the 33 players not multiple positions...to see if anyone would comment on how thats a good thing about your team.

I thought i would give a little hint out... with J. Oakley-Nicholls arguably the worst player still on a AFL list, also my poll were comments i have used in the past except Spud Team... eg Poor Team

[Master Q]

Some people found me out... i thought i shall tell everyone now.. this is definitely not the team i will have... in other words, fake team..

However i did put a few players up that i thought i would consider, as smokies.. eg Jurrah or Harlett

Some of this help was beneficial... and some people listed on how could improve this team, which still in a way help.. i went for a multiple postions line up aswell, only having about 8 out of the 33 players not multiple positions...to see if anyone would comment on how thats a good thing about your team.

I thought i would give a little hint out... with J. Oakley-Nicholls arguably the worst player still on a AFL list, also my poll were comments i have used in the past except Spud Team... eg Poor Team

What a load of rubbish. Learn to accept things.  ::)