2011 Membership Drive

[bomberboy0618]

If you took the best players from Carlton and the best players from Essendon, they still wouldn't be able to beat Collingwood!

How about this for a motto:

"We're paying Chris Judd illegally for you, help us pay his wages!"

It's accurate, not misleading, and leads to minimal disappointment.

Hit the nail on the head os

[Master Q]

If you took the best players from Carlton and the best players from Essendon, they still wouldn't be able to beat Collingwood!

How about this for a motto:

"We're paying Chris Judd illegally for you, help us pay his wages!"

It's accurate, not misleading, and leads to minimal disappointment.

Ossie that's becasue if Carlton and Essendon merged, it'd still be pretty much the same team  :P

[bomberboy0618]

essendon respects the fact that putting one player on the field isnt right though q

[Master Q]

essendon respects the fact that putting one player on the field isnt right though q

Well you wouldn't be able to do it anyway. And were not a one man team, Marc Murphy is a A Grade Player. Krooze is on his way, Gibbs if he works hard, and Simpson is B+.

[bomberboy0618]

so ur a 5 man team then q?

[Master Q]

so ur a 5 man team then q?

No team in the Comp is a 22-Man team.

And anyway, you can't forget Carrazzo, Betts, Yarran and Gartlett.

[bomberboy0618]

so ur a 5 man team then q?

No team in the Comp is a 22-Man team.

And anyway, you can't forget Carrazzo, Betts, Yarran and Gartlett.

at least some try q

[Master Q]

so ur a 5 man team then q?

No team in the Comp is a 22-Man team.

And anyway, you can't forget Carrazzo, Betts, Yarran and Gartlett.

at least some try q

So you're saying Carlton should try and get some good players? I think every club is trying to do that?

Or are you saying they should drop a Norm-Smith, Dual Brownlow Medal winner Premiership player Gun?

[roo boys!]

essendon respects the fact that putting one player on the field isnt right though q

Well you wouldn't be able to do it anyway. And were not a one man team, Marc Murphy is a A Grade Player. Krooze is on his way, Gibbs if he works hard, and Simpson is B+.

Agreed, Gibbs can be amazing on his day.

[Master Q]

essendon respects the fact that putting one player on the field isnt right though q

Well you wouldn't be able to do it anyway. And were not a one man team, Marc Murphy is a A Grade Player. Krooze is on his way, Gibbs if he works hard, and Simpson is B+.

Agreed, Gibbs can be amazing on his day.

If people stop being so Harsh on him many will think that as well.

[roo boys!]

*looks at Cruise ::)

[ossie85]

We can't be too harsh on Gibbs, he is young and lacks a quality coach.

[Cruiseon]

I guess that is my cue.....

Ahh Bryce, where do we start. It is not that he isn't a good player it is just that he really is quite soft and goes missing when the going gets tough. Bryce is a very good player when everything is going to plan and the Blues have the momentum but that is not what most clubs want from their best players. It is also not the best ingredient for a good finals player if Carlton intend to win a final one day.

(is that what you after Roo boy?.....always happy to help ;))

[bunyip]

Can I just say how disappointed I am in you Carlton guys. MQ is trying valiantly to maintain the rage all by himself. Ossie and cruis are having a great time at your expense.
Come on, some lively and quick witted response is required. Don't expect MQ to do everything. Wheres that old bluebagger spirit.
Collingwood are only a genuine target once in a blue moon, and you are letting them off.
Help MQ out will ya?

[Master Q]

Well you see, some Carlton supporters have a life bunyip, so there not here atm, unlike Collingwood supporters who live in a Tattoo Parlour, and don't leave till there is no such thing as skin.