AEPL Season Round 2 Draw/Trade discussion/Analysis

[CrowsFan]

Givet for Johnson
Scholes for Nani
Alex for Elmahomady

I don't see any one of those 3 trades being good for HP at all.
Johnson will score better than Givet even in an out of form team.
Nani will definitely score more than Scholes
Elmahomady has been playing as a winger so has chances of getting goals and assists, whilst Alex is no certainty to play again after coming back from injury with Bosingwa now fit again

[CrowsFan]

My Official Hit List:
Ashley Young
Dirk Kuyt
Robin Van Persie
Frank Lampard
Stewart Downing (to a lesser extent)
Stephen Carr

It would have to be a big offer to get me to give you Lampard ;)

[Justin Bieber]

My Official Hit List:
Ashley Young
Dirk Kuyt
Robin Van Persie
Frank Lampard
Stewart Downing (to a lesser extent)
Stephen Carr

It would have to be a big offer to get me to give you Lampard ;)

I'm seeing what I can pull up :P.

[chrisuzz]

My Official Hit List:
Ashley Young
Dirk Kuyt
Robin Van Persie
Frank Lampard
Stewart Downing (to a lesser extent)
Stephen Carr

It would have to be a big offer to get me to give you Lampard ;)

I'm seeing what I can pull up :P.

that's a fith of my team HP :o

[Justin Bieber]

Initial Offer:

Lampard, Gilks, Jagielka for Arshavin, Jaask, Johnson?

Lol, I know ZZ :P. Van Persie not high up though 8). Young number 1 target.

[CrowsFan]

Hmm I do like the look of that offer, but don't really want Johnson back, and Jagielka has been in good form recently cos Everton are starting to get some clean sheets. Any chance of a better defender? Or I could give you Boateng instead of Jag for a better defender?

[Justin Bieber]

Don't much like Boateng especially in a team like Man City.

Everton has been on a streak which picks Jags stocks :(. Maybe Dunne instead?

[Master Q]

HP, when Alex is back you will have 2 Chelsea defenders?

How about this:

Givet for Johnson
Nolan for Nani
Williamson for (Defender of Choice)

[Justin Bieber]

Nani could outscore all 3 of those guys :P. As I said before, Not a big fan of Givet's team and don't rate Nolan a whole lot. Williamson has Harper behind him :(. Not a great defender for me. All my defenders are probably better than him :P.


CF, I'll be willing to give up Elmohamady for any of your defenders, but lower Arshavin to Brunt (although if he continues on his hot streak, could be a great trade).

[chrisuzz]

Will you be willing to trade out Baines HP?

[Justin Bieber]

Will you be willing to trade out Baines HP?

Will take a bit to split up Baines, Vermalean and Ivanovic ;). They are my strong 3 and I started with them in the official one :P. You can offer but will have to be something BIG especially Everton have finally found form.

[CrowsFan]

Hmm I think I am going to have to say no to that. Think I will wait and see how Lampard performs when he comes back.

Don't understand why you wouldn't like Boateng? He is in the starting XI and plays along side a very strong defense with a solid keeper behind. What more could you want?

[Justin Bieber]

He is in their XI, but has only scored 8 points. Have only played 1 full game :-\. Need to see how he goes for a bit longer before I commit to him.

[chrisuzz]

Young + Young for Baines + Arshavin ????

Just a thought

[Justin Bieber]

Luke Young isn't worth that much :P. A no on my part ;).