marty clarke a pie again?

[Cruiseon]

Ossie - just to add they are all Premiership palyers, always will be. And it's just lovely that they are.

Let's just hope Clark, Tarrant, Dick, Krakouer all join the club.

[BoredSaint]

its funny how Collingwood are doing so many changes to the squad even though they won the flag..

and St kilda are doing shower all when our premiership window is closing..

[ossie85]

Most of Collingwood's were forced though, with a lot of retirements of players outside the best 22.

Saints should have been more active in trade week though. Heard rumour that Travis Johnstone could be a good fit at the Saints.... I'd run away!

[browny_wce]

I still find it amazing that Collingwood players STILL get crap LOL.

Toovey has "average" stats in conventional measures, but is by no means an average player.

Nathan Brown is in his 3rd year and is holding down a key position. How many players can do that? I can only think of James Frawley.

Brent Macaffer has been superb this year (particularly the second half of the year), and if you watched the first half the replay, I can't see how you could call him a spud.

Nick Maxwell is an All-Australian, Premiership Captain. You can call him underrated, but it is this simple - Collingwood would have lost the first grand final if not for him, he is a superb leader and one of the elite of the AFL.

Maxwell is made to look good! Its easy playing as a defender when u dont have to play on anyone, I've never seen him win a one on one contest. Did not deserve All Australian. Proving I'm not biased, Maxwell is the worst captain in the AFL (on own ability) only 2nd to Darren Glass.
As I said, I like Toovey, hes a good shutdown defender and does his job
There are alot better players then Macaffer
And yes no matter what Collingwood do, we will always hate them!  ;D

[Cruiseon]

Browny, how does it feel to be 16 spots below Collingwood? That is such a long way. It must also be annoying hearing how NicNat is moving to GWS, the only signs of hope moving away!

I think Maxwell could beat the entire Weagle forward line by himself, comfortably.

[browny_wce]

mate im sweet, eagles have won 3 flags in the AFL and i mean AFL not that VFL bull u pies supporters try n brag about.

Nic Nat can go to GWS for all i care, i didnt think we shudve picked him anyway, hes not a footballer (much like ur mate Maxwell)
and pretty sure Josh Kennedy or LeCras could carve up Maxwell, just Maxwell never goes on on one with anyone coz hes a hack n weak as piss