SUPERCOACH 2011 IDEAS

[mophead222]

Please rate my team,

BAC

B.Goddard (B/C), B.Deledio (B/C), S.Hurn, J.Drummond, B.Houli (B/C), A.Otten, J.Toy - X.Clarke (B/C), S.Iles, D.Talia (B/F)

MID

D.Swan, L.Hodge (C/B), P.Chapman (C/F), L.Anthony, D.Swallow, N.Foley - R.Ah Chee, A.Krakouer, M.Wallis

RUC

A.Sandilands, D.Jolly - Z.Smith, M.Daw (R/F)

FWD

N.Riewoldt, C.Rioli, A.Goodes (F/C), S.Sidebottom (F/C), P.Dangerfield (F/C), R.Petterd (F/C), D.Petrie (F/R) - J.Butcher, A.Hooper, B.Matera

Criticism wanted !!!!
  :)

[Junktimer]

Please rate my team,

BAC

B.Goddard (B/C), B.Deledio (B/C), S.Hurn, J.Drummond, B.Houli (B/C), A.Otten, J.Toy - X.Clarke (B/C), S.Iles, D.Talia (B/F)

MID

D.Swan, L.Hodge (C/B), P.Chapman (C/F), A.Swallow, D.Swallow, M.Wallis - R.Ah Chee, A.Krakouer, T.Liberatore

RUC

A.Sandilands, D.Jolly - Z.Smith, M.Daw (R/F)

FWD

N.Riewoldt, C.Rioli, A.Goodes (F/C), S.Sidebottom (F/C), P.Dangerfield (F/C), R.Petterd (F/C), D.Petrie (F/R) - J.Butcher, A.Hooper, B.Matera

Criticism wanted !!!!
  :)

I think your backline might be a little weak, i have big problems with houli despite his popularity.  Drummond is injury prone, but apart from that its ok.

Midfield is very good, cant go wrong with the swallow brothers.

Rucks are good.

I have a problem with goodesy, i think he may be too inconsistent. sidey will have a breakout year IMO, so good pick.  dangerfield IMO is a no-no, he killed me last year.

Overall good team, sorry bout all the criticism, you wanted it though.

8/10

[mophead222]

Houli is cheap tho, and he is looking like going to richmond so he will keep a spot in the side easier, also if drummond can stay injury free he will have a big year, always does if healthy.

Goodes will spend more time in the mid with kirk gone and bradshaw healthy.
also danger will most likely spend more time in the midfield with all of the players retire last season

[Junktimer]

Houli is cheap tho, and he is looking like going to richmond so he will keep a spot in the side easier, also if drummond can stay injury free he will have a big year, always does if healthy.

Goodes will spend more time in the mid with kirk gone and bradshaw healthy.
also danger will most likely spend more time in the midfield with all of the players retire last season

its only my two cents, not gospel

[mophead222]

i know, just wanting to explain why i chose them, and thankyou, finally someone agrees with me on sidebottom

[Junktimer]

i know, just wanting to explain why i chose them, and thankyou, finally someone agrees with me on sidebottom

hes a gun IMO

[tferrier18]

Sidey's locked in for me too! Showed unbelievable maturity and class in the grannys. It's absolutely ridiculous that he's 19

Anyway, your team...
Backs:
I think Toy is definitely capable of starting so no ciriticisms for your backline from me. 4 premiums will be enough to carry the load. I guess we'll all have to wait and see where houli ends up. And if Gibbs is in the backs for that matter.

Mids:
I'd prefer to see a mid pricer in your mids instead of Chapman or A. Swallow. Since you're using Chapman for mpp it would be Swallow. The reason for this is there is so much value in your mids but you're not leaving yourself much room to manoeuvre and take advantage of this by having 4 premiums. E.g I was going to have Boak in my team as 4th mid but you really can't go passed Foley who will probably score 5ppg less than Boak (assuming fit), but I'll have so much spare cash to use around the ground.

Fwds:
Would prefer another premium in there...Could use money from downgrading swallow to upgrade Danger..

Other criticisms; 2 pies players in mids, 2 dogs players in mids (including bench)

8/10 from me

[benjy251090]

Only real problem is the 2 bulldogs rookies in the mids and the 2 GC mid rookies, I would only take one of them, but rookies can wait until preseason

Also, watch your mid pricers in danger and houli as one can be downgraded and the other upgraded if they are in poor from :)

8.5/10

[mophead222]

yer, the rookies are not permenant, so i will definately fix those up in pre-season,

[mophead222]

how about that?

[benjy251090]

yeah, not too bad, backline looks a bit week for my liking though, how much you got spare?

[mophead222]

like 30k

[benjy251090]

maybe downgrade dangerfield and upgrade houli ???

[mophead222]

yer i might, but are there any reasonable options for the downgrade and upgrade?
and also as you said imo danger will have a breakout year in the mid

[benjy251090]

Houli to Mzungu and Dangerfield to Brown maybe