If You Rate Mine I Will Rate Yours

[elephants]

great, thanks chrisuzz i have majak daw in my forward line soooo..... :)

i expect houli to go on to the draft and have the tigers pick him up. i feel like he will play very well in their young team and he is god value for money. also i satcked my forward line as i had trouble with it this year. by stacking it i am hoping it is a lock and leave :)

[Botak]

My first crack.....

Backs
Goddard, Broughton, Grimesy, Kelly, Houli, Otten, Mzungu
Josh Toy, Michael Coad, Sam Iles

mids
Swan, Deledio, Anthony, Foley, Swallow, Montagna
Dylan Mcneil, Xavier Clarke, Andrew Krakour

rucks
Sandi, Petrie
random dude, Zac Smith

Forwards
Riewoldt, Pav, Buddy, Brown, Knights, Pettard, Buddy
Lukas Makovic, Lucas Cook, Majak Daw

thanks guys any thoughts and critisizms welcome :) 90 k left over for improvements...i will rate yours if you rate mine :) also forward benches i have no clue on so they are just there to fill up space :P

Very similar backline to mine by the looks. I like your mids... Would you consider Sam Day at this early stage as a Bench Ruck?

[Barlow 21]

Sam day is wayyy to expensive as a benchie :P

[elephants]

yeah sammy day not for me he looks like jack watts :)

i am cnosidering dropping foley to a rookie like gaff? this would give me another 60 odd k on top of the 90 i already have :) thanks all

[browny_wce]

LE I agree with that move there. Think u need much better use of the quality miss in this years draft. Hope u can find better mpps then McNeil n Clarke aswell!
Other than that it's a pretty good team
Would also work on your forward rookies, try for lamb, darling, lynch, matera, smelts, or maybe even Callum Wilson instead of one of your premiums

[HTM]

i gave it 8/10

[popedelio]

Knights is a no go for me

[elephants]

yeah i am sure  can find someone better than clarke and mcneil (conca and heppel?) and yes maybe one rookie will fit :)

Thanks HTM

why popedelio?

[browny_wce]

Yeh why's that? I think alot of people have knights ready to go

[elephants]

only reason i could think of is injury history?

[browny_wce]

yeh i recon he could be like a Beau Waters tho

[elephants]

just thought i would give my thread a bump now that the draft is done and dusted, modifications are made on the first post :)

cheers LE :)

[browny_wce]

My first crack.....

Backs
Goddard (C), Kelly (C), Grimesy, Broughton, Houli (C), Adcock, Mzungu
Josh Toy, Cam Richardson, Ben Jacobs

mids
Swan, Didak (F), Anthony, Heppel (B), Swallow, Gaff
Shaun Atley, Mitch Hallahan, Josh Green

rucks
Sandi, Petrie (F)
Scotty Lycett, Zac Smith

Forwards
Riewoldt, Pav (C), Buddy, Brown, Knights, Pettard (C), Goodes (C)
Tom Lynch, Jack Darling, Majak Daw (R)

thanks guys any thoughts and critisizms welcome :) 220 k left over for improvements...i will rate yours if you rate mine :)

Cheers LE :)

Love the look of the update LE, rookies are looking better n premos are deff locks
Couple of minor dramas in Grimes n Houli in your backs, grimes as he maybe a bit rusty n may be put in cotton wool over the most minor bumps n bachar as his position in Richmonds team is uncertain, what with their plethora of young midfield talent + Conca
Also not sure about having two tall rookie fwds, they don't always score that well, wuld be happier with a Lamb, Harper or Matera in there
Hope i helped
Browny ;D

[elephants]

yeah had a look at the draft and i like what i see, thanks mate :)

locking in grimes for the old third year breakout rule (as if he hasnt already) but i think he will be solid considering the demons being in the rebuilding stage and looking to fire up the ladder. not sure on houli he says he wants to go to the tigers and they seem keen on him but we will see i have enough cash to upgrade to a gun ? anny suggestions? symes?

yeah the whole petrie mpp with a rookie is doing my head in. i was wanting to put petrie as a forward maybe for knights?

thanks for your help browny i think i am good but for the premo defender and my last point :)
thanks

[bomberboy0618]

9.5. Brennan is on my shortlist, him and ablett should be the go to men for gc.
Great team :)