If You Rate Mine I Will Rate Yours

[elephants]

My first crack.....

Backs
Goddard (C), Kelly (C), Gilbert, Grimesy, Broughton, Adcock, Mzungu
Josh Toy, Cam Richardson, Ben Jacobs

mids
Swan, Didak (F), Anthony, Heppel (B), Swallow, Gaff
Shaun Atley, Mitch Hallahan, Josh Green

rucks
Sandi, Jolly
Scotty Lycett (hopefully F), Zac Smith

Forwards
Riewoldt, Pav (C), Petrie, Brown, K. Harper, Pettard (C), Goodes (C)
Tom Lynch, Jack Darling, Jed Lamb 

thanks guys any thoughts and critisizms welcome :) 220 k left over for improvements...i will rate yours if you rate mine :)

Cheers LE :)

[benjy251090]

you are missing a back, a mid and half your forward line ::)

it looks like a good team though

did you steal my ruck line ;)

[elephants]

nah mate my backs and mids are fine. ucks maybe borrowed but sandi smith were always on my radar and daw is an MPP so he was there but i could have borrowed jolly. it was out of jolly, ryder, hille, coxy for second ruck but i figure the peis are the best team there. i have no idea on forward rookies if that is what you are eluding to with me mssing half my forward line. so i picked a couple of expensive rookies to take their place.

thanks for the feedback though mate :)

[benjy251090]

i mean there is now meant to be 3 benchmen for backs, mids and fwds

[elephants]

oh haha thanks mate i completely forgot. that must be why i have so much money left over :)

i now i have 250 k left over...

[Justin Bieber]

Maybe update the team up the top?

Looks good right now. Good mix down back. Midfield looks solid even though missing a benchie. Alot of good midfielders in this draft. Wouldn't be hard to find a cheap one here. Rucks seem great.

Forward line looks good. Brennan changing teams could do him well. Will it change his inconsistent way? Who knows.

Forward rookies..... Keep an eye out for Dixon and Matera of GC. Also Hooper from the Dogs. Maybe even Talia or Butcher. Both should see games next year with retirings. There will be more that pop up.

[benjy251090]

haha, no worries, it did look a little iffy with the spare money :P

[elephants]

thanks hp i just updated this as you posted :)

yeah tried to get some cheapies down back, got krakour in the mids as he won the sandover medal in the WAFL and he is looking really good :) rucks are lock and leave, and i am taking a punt on brennan i personally hope he goes to carlton or the bulldogs :)

thanks hp :)

[Justin Bieber]

Krakouer is in EVERYBODY's team ;D.

[elephants]

haha yeah and rightly so hp :)

[reesbr]

I rated yours an 8.

Looks very decent in all areas. Well done mate

[RobertHarvey35]

brennan and jolly are risky.  mids looks weak imo

[Boomz]

Very nice team imo... 8/10 I'd watch Brennan pre-season though.

[elephants]

yeah brennan looks good for me if he moves i am ready for his roller coaster. jolly in a very good team i feel as though could thrive. thanks reesbr. rob harvey i am prepared to sacrfice the strength of mids to gun up my other positions.

[Barlow 21]

9/10
Brennan is really the only concern so i`d watch him pre-season. ;)