I'll Have A Crack!

Started by HillHero13, September 27, 2010, 06:00:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

HillHero13

Backs:
Deledio, Broughton, Gilbee, Gram, Drummond, Mcveigh, Otten
X.Clarke, K.Hunt, Talia

Mids:
Ablett*, Goddard, Cross, O'Keefe, Schammer, D.Swallow
Liba, Blease, random

Rucks
Tippett, Petrie
Day, Smith

Fowards:
Didak, Stevie J, J Roo, S.Byrnes, Hall, L.Davis, Knights
Griffiths, Matera, Bruest


1 - 10 what ya think..

Boomz

Pretty good... Theres a few players I'm not sure about, Hall (Age), Schammer (Not really sure depends if he stays at freo), Mcveigh (If he plays as a mid then could be good) & Byrnes... Davis could bounce back but he is a slight worry too.

Other than that its a pretty good side!

chrisuzz

i was thinking of having Tippett and Petrie as 2nd ruck nd 6th or 7th fwd

benjy251090

honestly, not a fan of some of the players, especially some that BOOMZ mentioned, you have a solid core though you just need to tweek a bit, 6.5 out of 10

Barlow 21

I`ll tell you one thing Hill Hero. Stay away from Schammer

elephants


Justin Bieber

Quote from: BOOMZ on September 27, 2010, 06:07:41 PM
Pretty good... Theres a few players I'm not sure about, Hall (Age), Schammer (Not really sure depends if he stays at freo), Mcveigh (If he plays as a mid then could be good) & Byrnes... Davis could bounce back but he is a slight worry too.

Other than that its a pretty good side!
Agree with Hall about age. But is a focal point at the Dogs and still serviceable. Won't expect miracles from him.

Schammer can rack it up but his efficency and decision making kills him. I had him 2 years ago and was quite happy (when I knew nothing about fantasy footy). Likely going to change clubs if not going to the Suns this trade period.

McVeigh will get games. Likely off half back/forward. A Smokie but will watch where Hird plays him during the pre season.

Byrnes is quite good. Just very inconsistent as is Davis. Byrnes has more potential since he plays forward regulary. Davis usually played midfield which saw his scores rise. But his move to foward pocket has not been good for him. Would avoid him unless that changes (which I highly doubt).

On the team as a whole, Don't like both Tip and Petrie in the rucks. Look to move one into the forward line for MPP and take in another ruck.

And I might add DO NOT get a random in the mids next year. Have alot of great midfielders in this draft. Do not let them slip and miss a good cash cow.

HillHero13

Quote from: Hellopplz on September 27, 2010, 11:31:41 PM
Quote from: BOOMZ on September 27, 2010, 06:07:41 PM
Pretty good... Theres a few players I'm not sure about, Hall (Age), Schammer (Not really sure depends if he stays at freo), Mcveigh (If he plays as a mid then could be good) & Byrnes... Davis could bounce back but he is a slight worry too.

Other than that its a pretty good side!
Agree with Hall about age. But is a focal point at the Dogs and still serviceable. Won't expect miracles from him.

Schammer can rack it up but his efficency and decision making kills him. I had him 2 years ago and was quite happy (when I knew nothing about fantasy footy). Likely going to change clubs if not going to the Suns this trade period.

McVeigh will get games. Likely off half back/forward. A Smokie but will watch where Hird plays him during the pre season.

Byrnes is quite good. Just very inconsistent as is Davis. Byrnes has more potential since he plays forward regulary. Davis usually played midfield which saw his scores rise. But his move to foward pocket has not been good for him. Would avoid him unless that changes (which I highly doubt).

On the team as a whole, Don't like both Tip and Petrie in the rucks. Look to move one into the forward line for MPP and take in another ruck.

And I might add DO NOT get a random in the mids next year. Have alot of great midfielders in this draft. Do not let them slip and miss a good cash cow.


i just love it how we can say that now!!

HP search Ryan Hill Berwick in facebook and look at my DP.. it's the best..

Justin Bieber

Ok? ???. Are you the guy with Hird Comes Home? :P.

HillHero13