AEPL Game Analysis (PS W1)

Started by Master Q, September 24, 2010, 09:49:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

chrisuzz

Hilly's Heroics
ZZ's Zanny Zebra's
Q's Champions
Hello
Didhedive Drogba

these teams are all left right??

So the 3 worst scorers are eliminated leaving two teams then we have a final

Master Q

That seems to be the best option so far, but, it is unfair to those who won their games.

benjy251090

just get fletch to flip a coin, heads hilly is in, tails Zz is in?

chrisuzz

make a thread put some of the best options up, let people suggest some idea and then make a poll and let everyone vote on it, thatll be the best way

Master Q

Quote from: chrisuzz on September 28, 2010, 06:56:37 PM
make a thread put some of the best options up, let people suggest some idea and then make a poll and let everyone vote on it, thatll be the best way
You can do that  ;)

chrisuzz

Quote from: benjy251090 on September 28, 2010, 06:55:31 PM
just get fletch to flip a coin, heads hilly is in, tails Zz is in?
yeah but wouldnt that be unfair if one of us get the top score next week


what about me or Hilly play Q and if Q wins he goes through but for example say it was Hilly vs Q and Hilly wins if i score more than Hilly i go through

Master Q

That's still me playing both of you, it's no difference.

chrisuzz

yes there is cos i may score higher than you but might not end up going through

Fletch74

Quote from: chrisuzz on September 28, 2010, 07:17:08 PM
yes there is cos i may score higher than you but might not end up going through
That's still not fair cos maybe you should be playing Q first....

I think perhaps the best result is perhaps is to perhaps look at what each of you might have scored in the either the previous week, or perhaps the whole season to date using the same formation that you chose this round??

Thoughts?

CrowsFan

How about whoevers captain scored more goes through, because they made a better choice for captain?

Fletch74

Quote from: CrowsFan on September 28, 2010, 09:59:26 PM
How about whoevers captain scored more goes through, because they made a better choice for captain?
That would be Zz because he chose Rooney, but it's not fair on HH cos I chose his team and I chose Lennon, he may have chose Tevez, thus he would have gone through...

Fletch74

Quote from: Fletch74 on September 28, 2010, 09:58:05 PM
Quote from: chrisuzz on September 28, 2010, 07:17:08 PM
yes there is cos i may score higher than you but might not end up going through
That's still not fair cos maybe you should be playing Q first....

I think perhaps the best result is perhaps is to perhaps look at what each of you might have scored in the either the previous week, or perhaps the whole season to date using the same formation that you chose this round??

Thoughts?
Based on that and choosing the bext player as captain, Hilly would win... So they are my options. Falling short of that, I don't know what else there is to do other than flip a coin or use the random website that I used for the draw?

Or, the other possibility is that I could pick a number between 1 and 100. I'll PM it to someone else so that I have a witness. Then both Hilly and Zz have to pick a number and the closest to that number wins.

benjy251090

i like that second one with the number between 1 and 100, i can be your witness

Hawka


Fletch74

Quote from: benjy251090 on September 28, 2010, 10:17:35 PM
i like that second one with the number between 1 and 100, i can be your witness
I have PM'd benjy the magic number. Hilly and Zz need to guess a number between 1 and 100. The closest goes through to play Q.

Note: Remember, this is only pre-season.

Also can't believe there are no trades this week :) Makes my job easy