My first 2011 plan

Started by Maca24, September 16, 2010, 06:19:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Maca24

Backs. Goddard, Hodge, Kelly, Drummond, Houli, Adcock, Otten.
           (Coad, Talia, X.Clarke)

Mids. Swan, Judd, Deledio, D.Swallow, Bennell, T.Houlihan.
         (M.Sewell, M.Wallis, J.Strauss)

Rucks. Sandilands, Petrie (Z.Smith, N.Vardy)

Frwds. P.Chapman, N.Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Goodes, Knights, Matera.
           (Tapscott, A.Krakouer?, J.Darling)

Bank. 15k
MPP with deledio and goddard.
I know its hard to judge since its such early days but I just felt like making a team. Enjoy  :)

tferrier18

Looks pretty good to me mate...

The only player I would advise against is Heath Shaw.

Reasons being (P.s I am an avid pies supporter)
- There are other premiums who are better options at that price
- Heath Shaw doesn't provide as much run as he used to because he isn't given nearly as much space anymore
- Kicks a clanger most games and has quite a few ineffective kicks that don't necessarily hit targets
- Harry O' is performing a similar quarter-back role so the magpies defence doesn't always look to Shaw to release and load up from the backline

I had Heath Shaw in my side this year and he wasn't what I was expecting. I've got a soft spot for him and I try to think he'll get better at handling a tag but he just doesn't.

Other than that I can't find a flaw in your side...maybe Brennan and adcock can be critisized.

Not sure if you'd actually be able to afford this team though. Looks pretty ridiculous

benjy251090

dont think matera is a mid, i think he is only a forward, look at liberatore for a mid spot or maybe even sewel's little brother, should be picked up in the rookie draft

Maca24

Thanks guys for the help. I did the maths and it fits in a 10.5m salary cap, which im presuming will be the salary cap for next year. went brennan for something different but yea. ill put liba in now.  :)

Maca24

Made a few edits. Couldn't pick between hayes and bartel. Would depend on Gaza leaving or staying. If he leaves I pick Bartel.

benjy251090

the team definitely has potential, nice work

Maca24

Thanks benjy. Im pretty happy. especially with the forwards.
Looking forward to the fanplanner aswell.  :D

benjy251090

yeah, i am waiting until fanplanner to make a full team, but i am putting my ideas in the SC Strategy section ;)

Barlow 21

Maca24, I`d only pick Houli if he gets regular games during pre-season or moves clubs. He isn`t getting any opturtunitys at Essendon. He`s on my shortlist. 8)

Maca24

thanks barlow. I think if he stays with a new coach he will get regular games. If he moves however, it would depend on which club he moves to. If its richmond then I cant fit him in as I want deledio  :)

Barlow 21

What do you think of Hamish Hartlett?

Maca24

nice unique. However i find him to be a bit injury prone and there are better options for less money. If he is fit with a full preseason I wouldnt rule him out.  :)

Barlow 21

What was your overall rank last year Maca?

Maca24

Had a shocker. 22,000th missed out on pods and rocky and got hit hard by injury. Thats why my 2011 plan is alot safer than this years team lol.
anyway back to topic  :D should i go hayes or bartel mate?

Barlow 21

If Ablett leaves go Bartel as Selwood will take the main tag while if Gazza stays take Hayes as a Cheap Premium.