Trade for Taz

[Hawka]

Valky is int that weird we have only 4 tall fwds buddy,roughy,dowler,lisle

And with our ruckmen 2 grimley and lowden are raw and young,, bailey is risky with injuries,,skipper is good but a bit of lack of height,,taylors a spud,,Rebouf is the only 1 i can have a point agianst

Dont like roughy up back i only want changes to our tall b acks if the new defender is better or almost better then our current defenders roughy isnt,thorton isnt but tarrant is

[valkorum]

10 talls and 6 of them are ruckmen. If a deal can't be done for Taz with Collingwood I think you guys are the next best option.  My personal order of preference:

Taz for Goldsack
Taz for 2 Beau's

[Hawka]

u wont get the first deal done and the hawks 1 seems good

[valkorum]

I agree that we prob won't get the first trade done. Not sure what trade we can do with the Pies to satisfy both teams

[hawk_88]

That was just a stat I read on the live chat on AFL.com.au on Monday.

According to the listing on this site, they are equal first with 3 other clubs (with 6). However if I do a count myself we have 7 (Renouf, Bailey, Skipper, Taylor, Lowden, Grimley, Sierakowski) so I am not sure of the accuracy of the data on this site.

Dowler isn't even worth counting, we don't trade him we delist him. We have plenty of height apart form in defence. That is where we should be concentrating (as well as adding some pace) not on another ruck/tall forward.

As for Taz, 70% of me still thinks he will go to the Pies (they notoriously play hard ball) however the longer it goes without a deal the lower that number goes in my opinion anyway.

[Hawka]

Sierakowski may not last the yr out bein on the rookie list and all
If we get hale or robbie campbell back taylor will b delisted

[valkorum]

Harvey and Chris Scott both said on talkback radio over here that we want a player for Taz, not a draft pick

[Hawka]

well dowler and muston fit the young player bill and u could take 1 away and add laddo if u wanted a premiship player i woudnt mind that deal

[valkorum]

I personally like Dowler and isn't Muston from WA?

[Hawka]

No was recrirted from sheparton may have been there wen younger butu may b thinkin of jarrayd morton who is from claremont WA

[hawk_88]

I can't understand why Freo would turn down Anthony. They want a premiership player, but he would be in most team's best 22, the Pies just have a surplus of key forwards (and most other types of players too). I am not his biggest fan, but you can't argue with results and 50 goals in a season is a lot.

Not unhappy if they don't take him though as it can't hurt our chances....

[ossie85]

Hale is useless we don't need him I don't want him at Hawthorn. We need a decent ruckman not a washed up one

That's what the Roos were saying about Leigh Brown. Who knows? Perhaps big-Roo men are destined to play better elsewhere

[Hawka]

Hope so

[valkorum]

No was recrirted from sheparton may have been there wen younger butu may b thinkin of jarrayd morton who is from claremont WA

Thats the one - I knew one of the possible players you could trade was from WA

[Hawka]

we do have buddy and bateman but there off limtis  :P