Duffs or Broughts

[elephants]

i had duffield this year and last year and boughton just last year :)

which should i get next year? my main rival is getting broughton  ???

which has the higher scoring potential for next year ?
thanks guys LE

[Hawka]

Duffy can b a little inconsisent and i think broughton has the potential 2 score more

[McRooster]

Get him interested in Sylvagni  ;)

Had Broughton last year and Duffman this year too, in a year of the emergence of the forward tag  >:(

[elephants]

yeah thats what i was thinking, both have the chance of being tagged but i will take broughton on the old 3rd year player rule even though duffield is one of my favourtie players (along with jimmy) :(

[Hawka]

yer duffield is 1 of my favs as well

[Holz]

i personally dont like getting backman that arent super premiums (Goddard,Hodge,Gibbs) or injured returning players (otten, harris) or rookies

[Holz]

saying that i would porbably go broughton if i had to make the choice, its hard not picking your favourite players this year i didnt get judd and harvey and next year im thinking of droping jimmy as well so i will have none of my favourite players. I felt a bit dirty replacing harvey and judd for my 2 more disliked players in voldt and ablett

[DT87]

I'm going with Broughton. I honestly think everyone who is trying to make the top 1000 next year should lock in one of these two guys - I just see too much downside in every back who averaged between Broughton's avg and Goddard's avg this year (Hodge & Lake too inconsistent and unpredictable, Gibbs scoring too low as a back, Gilbert same team as Goddard, etc).

[Holz]

I'm going with Broughton. I honestly think everyone who is trying to make the top 1000 next year should lock in one of these two guys - I just see too much downside in every back who averaged between Broughton's avg and Goddard's avg this year (Hodge & Lake too inconsistent and unpredictable, Gibbs scoring too low as a back, Gilbert same team as Goddard, etc).

I always find except hodge and goddard you never know what defender will be a premium that year e.g hargrave falling and lake climbing thats why i plan to only get hodge goddard and one other and the rest fill with players like otten.harris,adcock and spend more on mids where it seems that the top midfielders remain there generally

[benjy251090]

I'm going with Broughton. I honestly think everyone who is trying to make the top 1000 next year should lock in one of these two guys - I just see too much downside in every back who averaged between Broughton's avg and Goddard's avg this year (Hodge & Lake too inconsistent and unpredictable, Gibbs scoring too low as a back, Gilbert same team as Goddard, etc).

I always find except hodge and goddard you never know what defender will be a premium that year e.g hargrave falling and lake climbing thats why i plan to only get hodge goddard and one other and the rest fill with players like otten.harris,adcock and spend more on mids where it seems that the top midfielders remain there generally

is that daniel harris who used to play for north?

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah benjy. Moved to the Suns so should see some games as an experienced head.

[benjy251090]

i know he moved to suns, i thought he was a midfielder though, not a backman  ??? that was going to be my question

[Holz]

he was played in the back and in the middle in his last season with the roos

[benjy251090]

ok, its just he is named as a mid on fanfooty, would be handy though, especially if he is named as an mpp!

[elephants]

yeah i am not entirely sold on gibbs yet. m gut feeling is go with him but i am not sure :/

i guess we have to wait for the fan planner :)